I think Marrone would get chewed up by the NYC media. He may be a good CEO type, but I need to see more from him. TC had to re-calibrate to succeed with the NYG and I don't know if Marrone can do the same thing. I don't dislike Marrone by any means, I just don't think he's earned it yet.
I absolutely do not want Mike Smith or Spags.
If McAdoo has Eli's backing, then go with him at this point. We've clearly committed to Eli, so we need someone he is on board with.
The Giants HC job is a top three job in the NFL, which means in the world. It would be a fast ascent by McAdoo, but Eli had a helluva year and with better in-game management we could have had three to four more wins, easily.