NLRB, Private School FBS Ruling | Syracusefan.com

NLRB, Private School FBS Ruling

As it pertains to this issue, it's because the NLRB only governs private entities not public.
But they would need to compete with the private schools and would just do the same thing even if they were not forced to. We already know who wins these types of arms races...the public schools.

My comment is related to the assertion that private schools would have a leg up after this. They won't. The large state universities would.
 
Another fine piece of bird cage liner by Bud. Whether one agrees or disagrees with his sentiment, Bud really lost out on what could have caused some real analysis and thought.

Real Costs:
Tution
Board
Books
Lab fees
Gear (not including safety equipment, uniforms, footwear, but the casual gear issued to players)

Real Hours:
Class attendance (cough, cough SEC, cough)
Practice
Film study
"Extra" workouts
Study

Then add in the periphery costs and hours.

Since SU costs $60K annually (Bud's assertion), we can use this as a true cost of attendance at every school. recall that State schools are/were funded by the State to keep tuition down. If State U's had to pay their own way for everything, the costs would be similar enough for a study.

How many 18-22 year old people earn $60K annually (tax free, too!)? How many people can turn natural talent into a cash boom that will lay the foundation for their remainder of their life (not limited to kids going pro, but does include the kids that earn their degrees)?

Personal Income: PINC-02 Using the
xls.png
18 Years and Over [<1.0 MB] table, the median income for all of the US in 2015 was $45,281 per every worker 18 and over.

The number increases for males when separated and shrinks for women. However, to be completely fair and assuming Title IX will have some teeth in Congress, the ladies will be included in any payroll scheme, as will all athletes.

That said, each student is already ahead of the average US worker by at least 33% base on tuition alone. Some will argue the hourly pay; however, these are college students, the majority of which will end up in salaried positions where hourly wages are not the norm. Besides, in the professional world, if we want extra knowledge (school) we generally do that on our time unless the business wants to allow work hours for study (usually directly related courses).

And this is just the starting point of this debate.

See, Bud, you could have stirred up a hornet's nest if you only did a little work.


*Disclaimer, I am ambivalent about paying players so long as academics are strictly enforced (see SEC, UNC and NCAA failure to do its job). Please don't try to argue with me on this, argue with each other, that's fine, but I simply do not care one way or the other. My only wish is that academics would be enforced. I am very glad to see that SU does not sacrifice its mission to be like other schools.
 
Another fine piece of bird cage liner by Bud. Whether one agrees or disagrees with his sentiment, Bud really lost out on what could have caused some real analysis and thought.

Real Costs:
Tution
Board
Books
Lab fees
Gear (not including safety equipment, uniforms, footwear, but the casual gear issued to players)

Real Hours:
Class attendance (cough, cough SEC, cough)
Practice
Film study
"Extra" workouts
Study

Then add in the periphery costs and hours.

Since SU costs $60K annually (Bud's assertion), we can use this as a true cost of attendance at every school. recall that State schools are/were funded by the State to keep tuition down. If State U's had to pay their own way for everything, the costs would be similar enough for a study.

How many 18-22 year old people earn $60K annually (tax free, too!)? How many people can turn natural talent into a cash boom that will lay the foundation for their remainder of their life (not limited to kids going pro, but does include the kids that earn their degrees)?

Personal Income: PINC-02 Using the
xls.png
18 Years and Over [<1.0 MB] table, the median income for all of the US in 2015 was $45,281 per every worker 18 and over.

The number increases for males when separated and shrinks for women. However, to be completely fair and assuming Title IX will have some teeth in Congress, the ladies will be included in any payroll scheme, as will all athletes.

That said, each student is already ahead of the average US worker by at least 33% base on tuition alone. Some will argue the hourly pay; however, these are college students, the majority of which will end up in salaried positions where hourly wages are not the norm. Besides, in the professional world, if we want extra knowledge (school) we generally do that on our time unless the business wants to allow work hours for study (usually directly related courses).

And this is just the starting point of this debate.

See, Bud, you could have stirred up a hornet's nest if you only did a little work.


*Disclaimer, I am ambivalent about paying players so long as academics are strictly enforced (see SEC, UNC and NCAA failure to do its job). Please don't try to argue with me on this, argue with each other, that's fine, but I simply do not care one way or the other. My only wish is that academics would be enforced. I am very glad to see that SU does not sacrifice its mission to be like other schools.
I agree with everything you said.
 
the ivy and little ivies are the closest thing to pure sports out there. i watch ivy league football and it is very good and entertaining. been to several upenn games over the years. i have gotten to enjoy small time college football as well. they are a nice change in atmosphere and competitiveness from big time stuff.
 
the ivy and little ivies are the closest thing to pure sports out there. i watch ivy league football and it is very good and entertaining. been to several upenn games over the years. i have gotten to enjoy small time college football as well. they are a nice change in atmosphere and competitiveness from big time stuff.

Good point. The Ivies do not offer athletic scholarships and the kids must progress academically to stay in school and on the team. This is probably the ideal and the original intent of the NCAA. However, the NCAA of late has been less than diligent in its enforcement activities. Perhaps if they would not waste a decade proving a self reported incident and spend a little time investigating a parent "selling" his son's services to the highest bidder (C. Newton's father, UF expelling the kid, Mississippi claiming the $250K was too steep and Auburn having one great season and then tanking), or completely fabricated (or should we refer to these as "cloud" classes) wherein the class, the students and the professors simply do not meet, do work or test (UNC). A far cry from an honest self report and subsueing 10 year investigation.
 

Similar threads

    • Like
Orangeyes Daily Articles for Tuesday for Football
Replies
6
Views
669
    • Like
Orangeyes Daily Articles for Friday for Football
Replies
8
Views
524
    • Like
Orangeyes Daily Articles for Wednesday for Football
Replies
5
Views
448
    • Like
Orangeyes Daily Articles for Monday for Football
Replies
5
Views
552
Orangeyes Daily Articles for Monday for Football
Replies
6
Views
467

Forum statistics

Threads
167,732
Messages
4,723,369
Members
5,917
Latest member
FbBarbie

Online statistics

Members online
304
Guests online
2,675
Total visitors
2,979


Top Bottom