Best recruits: Marrone, Shafer, Babers

[Crusty]

When I look back at the notable players recruited by each of our last three head coaches, there are plenty to go around. Here's my list - apologies to anyone I missed.
(I have given credit to the coach that kept a player when there was a coaching change.)

Marrone 2009-2012 (4 years)

1. Justin Pugh 1st Round Draft choice NYG
2. Alec Lemon Signed as NFL Free Agent Houston Texans
3. Cameron Lynch Signed as NFL Free Agent
4. Eric Crume Signed as NFL Free Agent Jack Jaguars
5. Sean Hickey Singed as NFL Free Agent NO Saints
6. Shamarko Thomas 4th Round Draft choice Pittsburgh Steelers
7. Terrell Hunt Tragic injury plagued career MVP 2015 Texas Bowl
8. Prince Tyson Gulley MVP 2012 Pinstripe Bowl
9. Dyshawn Davis Ranks sixth on Syracuse's career tackles for loss record list (37.5) CFBL Player
10. Jason Bromley 3rd Round Draft Choice of NYG
11. Jerome Smith Signed as NFL Free Agent Atl Falcons (last 1,000 yard rusher prior to this year)
12. Rob Trudo 4 year starter team captain 2015
13. Wayne Morgan invited to Jack Jaguars rookie camp
14. Edit Riley Dixon Seventh Round Draft pick Denver Broncos

Had verbal committment from Gus Edwards who flipped to Miami when Marrone bailed to the Bills.


Shafer 2013-2015 (3 Years)

1. Eric Dungey Signed as NFL Free Agent NYG Saved SU football
2. Ervin Phillips Ottawa Rebbacks CFBL
3. Evan Adams Signed as NFL Free Agent with Balt Ravens
4. Jamal Custis Signed as NFL Free Agent KC Chiefs
5. Eric Crume Signed as NFL Free Agent Jax Jaguars
6. Steve Ismael Signed as NFL Free Agent Indy Colts
7. Chris Slayton Seventh Round Draft pick NY Giants
8. Brisly Estime Signed as NFL Free Agent NY Jets Career ended with injury
9. Luke Arciniega Team captain 2015
10. Zaire Franklin Seventh Round Draft pick of the Indy Colts - one of 5 team captains
11. Sterling Hoffichter Seventh Round Draft pick of the atlanta Falcons
12. Aaron Roberts Started all 13 games at left guard on 2018 team, playing every snap in six contests
13. Cody Conway Undrafted Free Genet eventually signed with Denver Broncos
14. Antwan Cordey Nickel back on 2018 team

Babers 2016-2021 (6 Years)

1. Airon Servais
2. Alton Robinson 5th Round Draft choice Seattle Seahawks
3. Amba Etta-Tawo Jacksonville Jaguars signed Etta-Tawo to a three-year, $1.66 million contract as an undrafted free agent
4. Andre Cisco Third Round Draft pick of the Jack Jaguars
5. Andre Szmyt Groza Award Winner
6. Chris Elmore
7. Jonathan Kingsley
8. Joshua Black
9. McKinley Williams
10. Moe Neal No. 9 on Syracuse's all-time rushing list with 2,560 yards and 15 touchdowns on 485 carries
11. Nykeim Johnson
12. Sean Riley Signed as NFL Free Agent NE Patriots
13. Sean Tucker do I really have to say anything here?
14. Tommy Devito
15. Trishton Jackson Edit Signed as NFL Free Agent with LA Rams
16. Duce Chestnut
17. Garrett Williams
18. Ifeatu Melifonwu Third Round Draft pick of the Detroit Lions
19. Garrett Shrader
20. Edit Trill Williams Signed as NFL Free Agent with NO Saints now LB Atlanta Falcons

As far as averages go there is not a meaningful difference over the period or between head coaches.

 

[qdawgg]

Following……

 

[OttoinGrotto]

When I look back at the notable players recruited by each of our last three head coaches, there are plenty to go around. Here's my list - apologies to anyone I missed.
(I have given credit to the coach that kept a player when there was a coaching change.)

Marrone 2009-2012 (4 years)

1. Justin Pugh 1st Round Draft choice NYG
2. Alec Lemon Signed as NFL Free Agent Houston Texans
3. Cameron Lynch Signed as NFL Free Agent
4. Eric Crume Signed as NFL Free Agent Jack Jaguars
5. Sean Hickey Singed as NFL Free Agent NO Saints
6. Shamarko Thomas 4th Round Draft choice Pittsburgh Steelers
7. Terrell Hunt Tragic injury plagued career MVP 2015 Texas Bowl
8. Prince Tyson Gulley MVP 2012 Pinstripe Bowl
9. Dyshawn Davis Ranks sixth on Syracuse's career tackles for loss record list (37.5) CFBL Player
10. Jason Bromley 3rd Round Draft Choice of NYG
11. Jerome Smith Signed as NFL Free Agent Atl Falcons (last 1,000 yard rusher prior to this year)
12. Rob Trudo 4 year starter team captain 2015
13. Wayne Morgan invited to Jack Jaguars rookie camp

Had verbal committment from Gus Edwards who flipped to Miami when Marrone bailed to the Bills.


Shafer 2013-2015 (3 Years)

1. Eric Dungey Signed as NFL Free Agent NYG Saved SU football
2. Ervin Phillips Ottawa Rebbacks CFBL
3. Evan Adams Signed as NFL Free Agent with Balt Ravens
4. Jamal Custis Signed as NFL Free Agent KC Chiefs
5. Eric Crume Signed as NFL Free Agent Jax Jaguars
6. Steve Ismael Signed as NFL Free Agent Indy Colts
7. Chris Slayton Seventh Round Draft pick NY Giants
8. Brisly Estime Signed as NFL Free Agent NY Jets Career ended with injury
9. Luke Arciniega Team captain 2015
10. Zaire Franklin Seventh Round Draft pick of the Indy Colts - one of 5 team captains
11. Sterling Hoffichter Seventh Round Draft pick of the atlanta Falcons
12. Aaron Roberts Started all 13 games at left guard on 2018 team, playing every snap in six contests
13. Cody Conway Undrafted Free Genet eventually signed with Denver Broncos
14. Antwan Cordey Nickel back on 2018 team

Babers 2016-2021 (6 Years)

1. Airon Servais
2. Alton Robinson 5th Round Draft choice Seattle Seahawks
3. Amba Etta-Tawo Jacksonville Jaguars signed Etta-Tawo to a three-year, $1.66 million contract as an undrafted free agent
4. Andre Cisco Third Round Draft pick of the Jack Jaguars
5. Andre Szmyt Groza Award Winner
6. Chris Elmore
7. Jonathan Kingsley
8. Joshua Black
9. McKinley Williams
10. Moe Neal No. 9 on Syracuse's all-time rushing list with 2,560 yards and 15 touchdowns on 485 carries
11. Nykeim Johnson
12. Sean Riley Signed as NFL Free Agent NE Patriots
13. Sean Tucker do I really have to say anything here?
14. Tommy Devito
15. Trishton Jackson
16. Duce Chestnut
17. Garrett Williams
18. Ifeatu Melifonwu Third Round Draft pick of the Detroit Lions
19. Garrett Shrader

As far as averages go there is not a meaningful difference over the period or between head coaches.
View attachment 210584

Trishton Jackson cashed some NFL checks.

Also Trill Williams is missing from the Babers group and is a Miami Dolphin.

 

[Crusty]

Just added Riley Dixon duh.

 

[RandomGuy]

Trill is a dolphin. Trishton a viking. Martin with Arizona. Cooney was with NO(he and Hof in NE for a workout this week.)

 

[RandomGuy]

 

[sufandu]

If you're giving credit to the coach that retained a player during a coaching change, shouldn't a bunch of guys under Shafer: Dungey, Custis, Ishmael, Philips, etc, be under Babers?

Similarly, shouldn't Delone Carter and Ryan Nassib be under Marrone?

 

[orange_in_VA]

If you're giving credit to the coach that retained a player during a coaching change, shouldn't a bunch of guys under Shafer: Dungey, Custis, Ishmael, Philips, etc, be under Babers?

Similarly, shouldn't Delone Carter and Ryan Nassib be under Marrone?

Credit is going to the coaches retaining players in the classes when the coaching changes took place. ie Moe Neal

 

[tbonezone]

not a lot of NFL 1st rounders amongst them all. we're like a triple A CFL/XFL club. go eskimos !

 

[Crusty]

Credit is going to the coaches retaining players in the classes when the coaching changes took place. ie

If you're giving credit to the coach that retained a player during a coaching change, shouldn't a bunch of guys under Shafer: Dungey, Custis, Ishmael, Philips, etc, be under Babers?

Similarly, shouldn't Delone Carter and Ryan Nassib be under Marrone?

Carter was class of 2006 and Nassib class of 2008..Both are GRob recruits.