I agree with her, Jim Boeheim and you.
We have all seen what has happened with the grad transfer rule. What used to be an obscure occurrence has become commonplace. Schools invest 2 or 3, sometimes 4 years developing players and see them take off to better programs at the drop of a hat, allegedly because they want to major in a field their school doesn't offer. My understanding is most take one course and most drop out as soon as their season ends.
The NCAA has chosen to turn a blind eye to it.
Coaches make long term plans to maximize the scholarships they have available to work with. They are counting on their seniors to show up for their season season and to be key parts of the team. When they leave early, it causes many problems.
But it gets worse; some kids are graduating in 3 seasons, so they can transfer and become eligible immediately with 2 years of eligibility left. This is even more harmful to the programs that developed these players.
There is a cascading effect with these transfers, where the best programs tend to get the best grad transfers, then the schools that lost players look to replace them with grad transfers from other schools, which look to replace their lost players with other grad transfers, etc.
Attendance is down for college football and basketball. I believe TV viewership is down as well. The turnover because of the grad transfer rule has, IMHO, hurt fan interest in many programs. Players fans have become invested in and feel are theirs leave regularly. This is not what you want if you want college athletics to be popular, have strong support (and thus money).
Expanding the grad transfer rule is just going to make a bad situation worse. I believe rules were just changed so scholarships are awarded for a full 4-5 year period; not renewed yearly at the whim of the school. That was a good change and I think it should go the other way as well; if the school has to guarantee the scholarship for 4-5 years, the player should have to stay that time period as well.
Exceptions should be made in the event the school goes on probation or the head coach leaves. In those cases, the players should be allowed to transfer immediately.
I think this is fair to the players, the coaches, the fans and the TV networks that makes big time college athletics possible.