Most wins by a Latino pitcher: ...

Cowtown

Resident Frostback Interface
Joined
Jun 24, 2012
Messages
24,904
Likes
31,010
#1
Juan Marichal? Nope.
Pedro Martinez? Good guess but not even close.
Fernando Valenzuela? Keep trying.
Mike Cuellar? Not even warm.
Dennis Martinez? Close, but no cigar.
King Felix? About 80 wins shy of ...

Bartolo Colon becomes winningest Latin pitcher

So, is Big s e xy a HOF candidate? Marichal and Pedro are in. And Pedro (219) was a first ballot, with over 90%.
 
Last edited:

br801

Living Legend
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
12,293
Likes
21,676
#3
Juan Marichal? Nope.
Pedro Martinez? Good guess but not even close.
Fernando Valenzuela? Keep trying.
Mike Cuellar? Not even warm.
Dennis Martinez? Close, but no cigar.
King Felix? About 80 wins shy of ...

Bartolo Colon becomes winningest Latin pitcher

So, is Big s e xy a HOF candidate? Marichal and Pedro are. And Pedro was a first ballot, with over 90%.
No chance. Several outstanding seasons within a very long career isn't nearly enough to get him there. Everyone you listed has a superior body of work.
 
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
23,909
Likes
38,595
#4
Juan Marichal? Nope.
Pedro Martinez? Good guess but not even close.
Fernando Valenzuela? Keep trying.
Mike Cuellar? Not even warm.
Dennis Martinez? Close, but no cigar.
King Felix? About 80 wins shy of ...

Bartolo Colon becomes winningest Latin pitcher

So, is Big s e xy a HOF candidate? Marichal and Pedro are in. And Pedro (219) was a first ballot, with over 90%.
No. he is way behind Jim Kaat among others.
 

jncuse

Hall of Fame
Joined
Feb 19, 2012
Messages
9,446
Likes
11,884
#12
Dasher. The OP is about most wins by a Latino pitcher. I like Jim Kaat, but El Gato he ain't. :)
I'm pretty sure you brought it up in your post.

Good story, not a Hall of Famer. He is short on quality seasons, and doesn't have quite enough quantity to overcome it. What ultimately hurt him is that he only won 14 games total over 5 years between 2006-2010... after a Cy Young Season. Let's just say he had averaged a dozen in that period, he would now be at 290, and would do what is necessary to get to 300. That number would have been

He did have a couple of really good years. I did have the chance to see a couple of his starts when the Expos made a run at the Wildcard in 2002 and traded for him. And what a haul for the Indians ... Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore, and Brandon Phillips.

Muke Mussina has a better resume and has had to wait a few year... although at 63% he is going to make it at some point IMO.

Colon's resume is probably closer to Jamie Moyer or Dennis Martinez and they are not hall of famers.
 


3
Top Bottom