Kind of crazy to speculate on what the roster might look like a year from now - but if I had to guess I would say Cook and Rhefuss would be most likely to start and I would put Seebold as the leader in the clubhouse to be the third starter. I don't know if I see an incoming freshmen competing for a starting spot right away. A lot of variables going on, but I think a lot depends on how the coaches feel about Seebold/Cook and if they are comfortable with them as the starters. On the face of it I like that trio, but we have to see how they perform this season. The one issue I might have is they wouldn't have a true "shooter" in the Voigt/Bomberry mold, but certainly Garnsey wouldn't fill that if he were to come.
And big disclaimer, Garnsey would actually have to want to come to SU, no sure thing at all.