The easy answer is Art. He had a great college career, a good NFL career and a signature game registering 17 tackles against ND. He also was stuck playing for an incompetent head coach for most of his career but had the luxury of playing against Big East competition.
Chris Slayton has been a stalwart for this program. Extremely durable (knock on wood), keeps his head down and does his job. An old school player. A player that a no BS coach like a Belichick would want. Doesn’t quite have the accolades that Art ended up with but equally as valuable and may have a higher ceiling. Can’t go wrong with either.
Haven’t had an interior lineman as good as either of these since Tim Green.
Chris Slayton has been a stalwart for this program. Extremely durable (knock on wood), keeps his head down and does his job. An old school player. A player that a no BS coach like a Belichick would want. Doesn’t quite have the accolades that Art ended up with but equally as valuable and may have a higher ceiling. Can’t go wrong with either.
Haven’t had an interior lineman as good as either of these since Tim Green.