Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Knicks411, post: 2465875, member: 767"] It's honestly really close. I agree, Schilling had a better peak, he was nearly the best pitcher in baseball at his best. Mussina was probably never quite that good. But if you're asking me if I could draft one guy at the beginning of their career and have their career as it played out, I think I'd take Moose. he was just so consistent for so long. Schilling was hurt, not great for a few years in the middle. Moose was basically good for 30 starts a year for 15 years. Schilling won double digit games 10 times, Moose did it 17 times. Guy was just there every year. Schilling is the answer to a trivia question I just learned; only guy to win a WS game for 3 different teams [/QUOTE]