Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Melancer46, post: 3763236, member: 1674"] I don't think any of the "others" are debatable with Dak right now (though I think Kyler and Burrow in particular are capable of becoming that level of QB). I'd put Herbert below Dak for now but no doubt he had an amazing rookie season. For me, Mahomes, Rodgers, and Wilson are hands-down better. Assuming Dak continues to play at his usual level, I think he's up there with Allen, Lamar, Watson, and Brady, at least for now. Obviously Allen was incredible this season and may ultimately prove that this past year was no fluke. If that's the case, he's on the same level as my top 3. So for me, it's basically: Tier 1: Mahomes Tier 2: Rodgers/Wilson Tier 2.5: Allen Tier 3: Brady/Lamar/Watson/Dak in some order. At worst, Dak is #8 IMO, though I'd probably argue for him as #6. [/QUOTE]