Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="IthacaMatt, post: 4107112, member: 405"] Just based on a "gut test" - thinking about whether guys were considered the best of their era, regardless of the steroids, speed or other enhancing drugs players have taken over time - I consider these guys Hall of Famers: Alex Rodriguez David Ortiz Jonathan Pappelbon Barry Bonds Roger Clemens Manny Ramirez Andy Pettitte would be marginal based on his regular season record, but had a great post-season record and won multiple titles. If that gets Phil Rizzuto into the Hall, it should probably get in Pettitte. Andy also ate up innings like a workhorse from the 1970s or 1980s. [/QUOTE]