Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Day2, post: 4147731, member: 5348"] Williams had a negative dWAR. Williams and Edmonds could be the exact same hitter, but Edmonds still comes out ahead because he took runs away. Just because Beltre and Jones are HOFers doesn’t mean Rolen isn’t. They’re all in the top ten. Your argument would be like saying Melo isn’t one of the all-time great scorers in NBA history, despite fact he’s ranked 9th. That Kobe, Jordan, and LBJ are, but not Melo. [/QUOTE]