Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Alsacs, post: 2035900, member: 652"] This is how I see it. He is getting in because of the 2 SBs. However his season by season performance have never been the elite at his position. Somebody like Kurt Warner played shorter career but his play in those seasons was way higher at the position than Eli's best. Warner won a MVP, has finished top 5 multiple times. Was an all-pro first or second team multiple times. He won a SB, and lost 2 other SBs. Warner doesn't have the stats of Eli but Warner hasn't gotten in the HOF. The 2 SBs, stats and NY media factor will get Eli in. [/QUOTE]