Bill Orange
Moderator
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2011
- Messages
- 1,679
- Like
- 4,054
I don't understand why they're going to Charlotte. There are some downtown hotels from which you can walk to the arena but most people will have to drive. Don't think that because it's a pro arena that it's better than Greensboro. It's not. It's got an incredible number of luxury boxes but for almost everyone not in a luxury box, seating sucks. The concourses aren't as wide or as nice as Greensboro. Concourses matter a lot when you're in an arena from noon until nearly midnight. There were many negative comment about the arena the only time the ACC tournament was in the current Charlotte arena. The tournament used to be in Charlotte a lot but in a different arena that's been torn down. That older arena was quite nice apart from the fact that it took forever to get in and out of the parking lots. Don't expect Charlotte to be some great cosmopolitan city. It's not.
I think with the conference's first experience in NYC being at Barclays, followed by an immediate return to NC, it's more likely they end up alternating long-term than moving to MSG permanently, which may mean no MSG ever. The arena is fine at Barclays, although it obviously lacks the history - let's be fair here, that history matters way more to SU, Pitt, BC, ND and somewhat Louisville fans than it does to the rest of the conference.
The fan experience at Barclays will be good, but it won't hold a candle to MSG. Southerners aren't going to think it's cool to hang out in Brooklyn. They'll either whine about hipsters or being in the "hood" in Brooklyn, and there aren't enough places right around the arena to spill out into. I think anyone from Tobacco Road who spends one conference tournament at MSG would love it right away, but a lot of that is because they could spill out to the bars around the arena and enjoy the atmosphere. If their first experience doesn't include that, the resistance to a long-term agreement with MSG to have the tourney in NYC will go up significantly.
Jeepers said:Still think alternating sites is bad for continuity. I don't think the BE at MSG would have been nearly as good if it moved around.
hallcity said:Syracuse fans should not delude themselves into thinking that once ACC fans see a tournament in MSG that they'll be delighted to have the tournament there forever. I can get to Greensboro from my home in Raleigh in an hour and a quarter. How could I possibly be convinced that flying to NYC is better? NYC is a fine place but I go to the ACC tournament to watch hoops, not go to museums or plays. Greensboro is within easy driving distance of at least seven of the ACC schools, eight if you include Ga.Tech. There's no way that U.Va. fans can stream into NYC for an ACC championship game the way they streamed into Greensboro this year. MSG has many happy associations for Syracuse fans but not so much for most of the rest of the conference. The tournament will rotate through NYC but putting it there for good isn't going to happen. By the way, if you look on the Pitt board, you'll notice that their fans came away from Greensboro with somewhat altered opinions about having the tournament there, with some actually liking it. If I had to guess, I'd guess that Louisville fans won't mind Greensboro a bit. This tournament is going to rotate. It's the only thing to do with a conference that sprawls from Boston to Miami. I can't expect it to be in NC every year. Syracuse fans can't expect it to be in NY every year.
There's no place to spill out to in Greensboro.
Syracuse fans should not delude themselves into thinking that once ACC fans see a tournament in MSG that they'll be delighted to have the tournament there forever. I can get to Greensboro from my home in Raleigh in an hour and a quarter. How could I possibly be convinced that flying to NYC is better? NYC is a fine place but I go to the ACC tournament to watch hoops, not go to museums or plays. Greensboro is within easy driving distance of at least seven of the ACC schools, eight if you include Ga.Tech. There's no way that U.Va. fans can stream into NYC for an ACC championship game the way they streamed into Greensboro this year. MSG has many happy associations for Syracuse fans but not so much for most of the rest of the conference. The tournament will rotate through NYC but putting it there for good isn't going to happen. By the way, if you look on the Pitt board, you'll notice that their fans came away from Greensboro with somewhat altered opinions about having the tournament there, with some actually liking it. If I had to guess, I'd guess that Louisville fans won't mind Greensboro a bit.
This tournament is going to rotate. It's the only thing to do with a conference that sprawls from Boston to Miami. I can't expect it to be in NC every year. Syracuse fans can't expect it to be in NY every year.
My map program shows it to be a seven hour drive from Charlottesville to NYC, not five and a half. That's a long way to go on the spur of the moment.The drive from Syracuse to NYC is over 4 hours. The drive from Charlottesville to NYC is about 5.5 hours, and from Charlottesville to Greensboro is 3. Charlottesville to Charlotte is 4.5. None of that is really an "easy" drive. GT to Greensboro is 5 hours, so if that's within easy driving distance then UVA is within "easy" driving distance of NYC.
The atmosphere in NYC has nothing to do with plays and museums. Within 1-3 blocks of the Garden are TONS of great bars and restaurants, and fans of the different schools congregate in them. I know you're a Duke alum/fan, and I know you guys would have a huge presence there, so there would probably be a few designated Duke spots to drink, hang out and watch games. There would be a buzz all day long around the tourney, and you'd leave the bar for the games and walk a couple blocks and be there without having to worry about driving, parking, etc.
Meanwhile, the entire tournament becomes the talk of New York - the #1 media market in the country. This also makes it a bigger deal nationally. The entire thing becomes a huge recruiting tool. I know that fans of long-time ACC teams have no fond memories in MSG, but if they play there for a couple years, they will. My read on it is that there would be tons of Duke and UNC fans/alums there, both from having a strong presence there anyway and from making a trip out of it. I view those schools as the only ones that "really" matter in terms of getting it there long-term. I don't expect UVA, NC State, GT fans, etc to come around on it. If Duke, UNC and 'Cuse want it there, I think it might happen.
I live in Delaware, but I did live in NYC a few years. I'd go up to an ACCT in Brooklyn for the games, but I wouldn't expect it to compare at all to MSG. Quite frankly, if it is never at MSG, I think a rotation is in the best interest of the conference. If they can get MSG, I think that holding it there every year would be in the best interest of the conference. If you haven't watched Requiem for the Big East, watch it and see what that venue did for the conference. Right now people still view the ACC as a Southern conference, instead of what it should be seen as - an East coast conference that is by far the best hoops conference in the country. A tourney at MSG every year would cement it as such.
My map program shows it to be a seven hour drive from Charlottesville to NYC, not five and a half. That's a long way to go on the spur of the moment.
You are in error it is about 5.5 hrs drive time. You must have a very poor mapping program.My map program shows it to be a seven hour drive from Charlottesville to NYC, not five and a half. That's a long way to go on the spur of the moment.
longislandcuse said:I live in Atlanta now. I'm in driving distance to Charlotte and I don't give a ****. I'd rather drive or fly up to NYC then go to freakin Charlotte. You won't understand until you actually go to a Conference Tourney in NYC.
I think with the conference's first experience in NYC being at Barclays, followed by an immediate return to NC, it's more likely they end up alternating long-term than moving to MSG permanently, which may mean no MSG ever. The arena is fine at Barclays, although it obviously lacks the history - let's be fair here, that history matters way more to SU, Pitt, BC, ND and somewhat Louisville fans than it does to the rest of the conference.
The fan experience at Barclays will be good, but it won't hold a candle to MSG. Southerners aren't going to think it's cool to hang out in Brooklyn. They'll either whine about hipsters or being in the "hood" in Brooklyn, and there aren't enough places right around the arena to spill out into. I think anyone from Tobacco Road who spends one conference tournament at MSG would love it right away, but a lot of that is because they could spill out to the bars around the arena and enjoy the atmosphere. If their first experience doesn't include that, the resistance to a long-term agreement with MSG to have the tourney in NYC will go up significantly.