Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="HRE Otto IV, post: 1629604, member: 5685"] The problem is, in the end SU is not helping the kids. Both Knapp and Long are still going to play. So SU did not protect them physically. In addition, both kids will now get a worse education, which does nothing for their future careers. There really should be a uniform NCAA rule or at least a P5 rule. That is the only way to truly protect the kids. Having each school have their own rule, does nothing. As to SU's supposed 3 strike policy, why not allow for an immediate challenge from a 2nd opinion? If the concussion is reversed, the liability shifts to that doctor and not SU. If a kid is diagnosed by SU as having a concussion they cannot practice. So they have plenty of time to get an immediate 2nd opinion before healing. If that 2nd opinion comes back negative for a concussion, shouldn't that concussion come off the record? Wouldn't that be the fair thing to do? [/QUOTE]