Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="RF2044, post: 331265, member: 40"]
The question was about which coach inherited more talent at QB. The W/L record has as much to do with the coaching staff Nassib has played for than anything else. I'm fine to agree to disagree on this point, but let's not pretend that Nassib was viewed as the asset this coaching staff has developed him into--the guy couldn't even beat out Greg Paulus, who hadn't played the position in 4 years. There is even a vocal minority of posters who view Nassib as grossly inadequate--that doesn't make it true, but it bears mentioning that Nassib isn't viewed by some as being a liability in some respects. And if you want to talk about WRs hamstringing the play of the QB--which has certainly been true for Nassib to an extent--just imagine what Patterson was playing with [Moss, Lane]. Enough said.

Wow...completely disagree with your take on the RBs. I think it is time to just end this dialogue / mini argument, both because it is subjective and it is clear that you and I aren't remotely on the same page. But I think the facts speak for themselves at RB--it isn't a clearcut advantage to Marrone's group over GRob no matter how you try to spin it--you are significantly discounting what Brinkley and Rhodes accomplished.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?