Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="BuckyBrew, post: 238056, member: 2093"] It's pretty ridiculous to just assign a random % to what "should be called." Every particular instance will be different depending on just how "set" the defender is vs. how much force the offensive guy runs into him with, and if the offensive guy actually tries to avoid the defender or just goes directly into him. The only real problem I have with the way it is called now is that there are too many instances where a guy lifts off toward the hoop and the defender simultaneously takes that one extra step toward him (often to get out of the restricted circle) and then flops to get the charge. Those should definitely be blocks. I also think that charges shouldn't result in BOTH a foul and a turnover. The benefits of trying to draw them are just too great. It should just be a player control turnover rather than a personal foul. [/QUOTE]