Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="jncuse, post: 2877496, member: 1969"] Agree with Rivera and Mussina. I always thought Mussina should have been a few years earlier. Halladay was a clear hall of famer for me, but I do think first ballot should be for the true greats... and he was close, but I would put him in on my second ballot. That being said if everyone thought like me he would be off the ballot in year one... I disagree with Edgar Martinez, but not very strongly. I can live with it. Peak stats look great but are highly era and park inflated. It would just be better if Bonds and Clemens got in, so they stop taking spots on the ballots from other deserving candidates. I was surprised to see Omar Vizquel at 42%. This early into the HOF process he seems like he could ultimately work his way to 75%. [/QUOTE]