Coverage Was Disappointing ?

[Newhouser]

Boeheim was very smart this is stupid. Like epically stupid. Faults sure but the man was light years ahead of most coaches on the EQ of the job and genius level consistency. Discounting the very end which happens to most

There is more to being smart than being smart in your career. He was a smart guy and a very good basketball coach who, like many public figures, thinks that success makes him an expert on everything, it doesn't.

 

[EnviroSciGuy]

Yes. This really isn't hard to figure out. JW doesn't think Autry got all the support he needed last offseason. That's why they hired Kline to run scouting. That's why they've (reportedly) beefed up NIL. That's why they've opted in to the House revenue sharing parameters.

Now, we can disagree with JW's assessment. We can lay the blame much more squarely at Red's feet for being utterly unprepared to acquire players via the portal, and for being negligent in carrying out his fundraising duties.

But if Kiyan went to USC Autry would still be getting a 3rd year. It's plain as day.

I don't think it was in Wildhack's hands. "Not getting the support he needed" might be the justification for retaining Red, but I think his general silence on the issue speaks volumes.

His hands are tied until next March.

 

[EnviroSciGuy]

I don't think there has been some grand conspiracy or anything.

Basically, people who are big fans of Boeheim spent 2017 through 2023 handwaving away the obvious decline of the program. It was a natural reaction to defend the guy that built a nationally relevant, title-winning program.

And JB gave them juuuust enough ammo for that defense... the 2018 and 2021 Sweet 16 runs. Plus, the sentiment that the legend gets to choose when he steps aside wasn't egregious in the abstract.

I will always contend that forcing Boeheim out in March of 2023 was predicated on installing Autry as head coach. There were a lot of folks -- boosters, former players, board members -- who would have been happy to let JB coach forever. I have zero doubt that JB would still be head coach as we speak if a few powers-that-be hadn't finally had enough two years ago this week. Red was the compromise. Boeheim leaves but we hire internally, the guy you all know and like.

It just hasn't worked out.

Exactly right. I wouldn't call it a conspiracy, but the folks who wanted to keep it in the family found Red as the perfect way to do so, and they won out.

And they are not owning up to the mistake.

 

[Dmcnabbrules]

Look, at some point it needs to be acknowledged that JB was a good coach but not a good guy.

That doesn’ make him unique.

Bob Knight. Jim Calhoun. The list goes on.

Plenty of guys in the same psychological syndrome who arguably did as much harm as they did good.

This couldn’t be further from the truth. He and Julie have done a ton for this community. Many things you never hear about. Is he grumpy yes, but to say he isn’t a good guy is incorrect.

 

[RF2044]

Question. If not for Melos kid coming to SU would Red have been retained?

If this is factoring into the decision in any way, shape, or form -- it makes the situation even MORE absurd.

 

[cusefan88]

I'm honestly shocked Team Melo is ok with what they've seen so far.

 

[RF2044]

Exactly right. I wouldn't call it a conspiracy, but the folks who wanted to keep it in the family found Red as the perfect way to do so, and they won out.

And they are not owning up to the mistake.

And it WAS a mistake.

It has backfired horribly on the program, which has slipped into further decline.

 

[Scooch]

Exactly right. I wouldn't call it a conspiracy, but the folks who wanted to keep it in the family found Red as the perfect way to do so, and they won out.

And they are not owning up to the mistake.

I'm not sure I care what people own. We'll know with certainty soon enough if it truly was a mistake. There's a universe where we'll know this summer, long before the team takes the floor.

 

[RF2044]

I'm not sure I care what people own. We'll know with certainty soon enough if it truly was a mistake. There's a universe where we'll know this summer, long before the team takes the floor.

I only care from the perspective that I don't want this process repeated, with unqualified people in the administration / BoT getting involved.

I suspect that most everyone involved recognizes that this went poorly. So mea cuplas are irrelevant.

 

[Scooch]

I only care from the perspective that I don't want this process repeated, with unqualified people in the administration / BoT getting involved.

I suspect that most everyone involved recognizes that this went poorly. So mea cuplas are irrelevant.

Fair. If the Fran search is any indication, it will be JW running things if it comes to that.

I don't think anyone was really "involved" when Red was hired. He just happened to be the guy sitting in the lucky chair when JB was pushed out.

 

[EnviroSciGuy]

I'm honestly shocked Team Melo is ok with what they've seen so far.

Hopefully they are clamoring for some staff upgrades and helping to make some changes internally. Melo has been pretty classy and professional throughout his career.

If he's working on things, he's doing it the right way.