Listen, I'm one of AO's biggest fans, but come on! He did almost nothing his freshman year, save one game where he got 8 rebounds in like 10 or 12 minutes, prompting JB to call him "a very interesting player."
To say AO as a freshman compares favorably to Coleman right now is just ludicrous. There was no sign in AOs freshman year that he would turn into the automatic scorer down low that he became after his red shirt season. As raw as he is, Coleman is on another level. Yes, DC2 has missed more than his share of bunnies, but his FG% is 47%, hardly a disaster. And he's already scored in double figures twice, with a high of 14 points already. And he's rebounding as well as AO ever did over the course of a season, in terms of rebounds per minute of play. And DC2 shoots free throws much better, a huge drawback about AO.
AO showed a brief flash of his potential freshman year, but it was hardly a foregone conclusion that he was going to be great. What was so great for us fans was that, like Rautins, AO lived up to his best-case projection as a player. DC2's mid-range projection is better than AOs best-case projection.