Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="cuse309, post: 1957231, member: 5119"] It's nuts to assume that because Mahoney is not a Division 1 caliber QB, and the other two are to the point where they had major offers. So to assume Mahoney will beat either is nuts given what he has shown with his arm, or should I say not shown. My argument that starting a true freshman will be less than ideal over starting Dungey holds true. It's a momentum killer, because we will likely have to sit through the growing pains of a Freshman learning the ropes. Your 3 qb's does not strengthen your argument. It just shows it's possible. Possible but highly, highly unlikely. We both know that more often than not, a freshman qb plays like a freshman qb, and not like McNabb, Graves, or McPherson. They are the exception to the rule. So, yes, in my opinion, starting a either freshman next year, with an even tougher schedule, will likely kill momentum gained this year. [/QUOTE]