Get To See Jameis Winston in the Dome Next Fall | Syracusefan.com

Get To See Jameis Winston in the Dome Next Fall

OrangePA

OrangePA

Living Legend
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
10,074
Like
15,260
Will he be the best QB to ever make an appearance in the Carrier Dome?

I have seen Doug Flutie, Dan Marino, Tony Eason, Teddy Bridgewater, Oliver Luck, Gino Torretta, Michael Vick, Sandy Schwab, Alex Van Pelt, Shane Matthews and of course Donovan McNabb, Todd Philcox, Marvin Graves and Donnie McPherson.

Who am I forgetting?
 
I second Pat White, he was awesome. Who was Florida's QB when they came up here and got beat?
 
OrangePA said:
Will he be the best QB to ever make an appearance in the Carrier Dome?

I have seen Doug Flutie, Dan Marino, Tony Eason, Teddy Bridgewater, Oliver Luck, Gino Torretta, Michael Vick, Sandy Schwab, Alex Van Pelt, Shane Matthews and of course Donovan McNabb, Todd Philcox, Marvin Graves and Donnie McPherson.

Who am I forgetting?
Expand...
Kirk herbstreit. :)
 
OrangePA said:
Will he be the best QB to ever make an appearance in the Carrier Dome? I have seen Doug Flutie, Dan Marino, Tony Eason, Teddy Bridgewater, Oliver Luck, Gino Torretta, Michael Vick, Sandy Schwab, Alex Van Pelt, Shane Matthews and of course Donovan McNabb, Todd Philcox, Marvin Graves and Donnie McPherson. Who am I forgetting?
Expand...

Glenn Foley, 1993. That was a passing clinic.

Tom Brady, 1999. That wasn't.

Just missed Peyton Manning by one year.
 
Speaking of next year, I am beginning to think that SU Football will post their 2014 Schedule before SU Lacrosse. I know some/most of those lax games have trickled in, but to not have a schedule finalized is stupid.
 
SU94 said:
Ken Dorsey (Miami FL) was a heck of a QB in his time.
Expand...

Certainly had 2 great passing days in the Dome.
 
OrangePA said:
Will he be the best QB to ever make an appearance in the Carrier Dome? I have seen Doug Flutie, Dan Marino, Tony Eason, Teddy Bridgewater, Oliver Luck, Gino Torretta, Michael Vick, Sandy Schwab, Alex Van Pelt, Shane Matthews and of course Donovan McNabb, Todd Philcox, Marvin Graves and Donnie McPherson. Who am I forgetting?
Expand...

Troy Nunes

Sent from my iPhone using Forum Runner
 
He won't be the best QB to ever play in the Dome. He might be at the bottom of a Top 10 list, but not the best.

He might be the best within the past decade, but not the best ever
 
I figure the line on that game will only be Cuse +35, easy money. :rolleyes:
 
Stern said:
He won't be the best QB to ever play in the Dome. He might be at the bottom of a Top 10 list, but not the best.

He might be the best within the past decade, but not the best ever
Expand...


If you're going to make a statement like this, you should back it up with your own top 10 list.
 
OrangePA said:
Will he be the best QB to ever make an appearance in the Carrier Dome?

I have seen Doug Flutie, Dan Marino, Tony Eason, Teddy Bridgewater, Oliver Luck, Gino Torretta, Michael Vick, Sandy Schwab, Alex Van Pelt, Shane Matthews and of course Donovan McNabb, Todd Philcox, Marvin Graves and Donnie McPherson.

Who am I forgetting?
Expand...
Andrew Robinson
 
OrangeHeel said:
Won't get to see him. Hear they're moving the FSU game to Toronto as part of an SU/Bills Saturday/Sunday doubleheader.

(Announcement coming right after Oklahoma to the Big Ten press conference.)
Expand...

Hey, I would much prefer going to the Skydome than the Meadowlands any day! If the powers-that-be insist on playing a "home" game away from our Dome, I'd much rather see it played in Toronto than Joisey.
 
SU94 said:
Ken Dorsey (Miami FL) was a heck of a QB in his time.
Expand...

Agreed, great college QB. He put on a clinic against Cuse, a couple of times.
 
OrangePA said:
Will he be the best QB to ever make an appearance in the Carrier Dome?

I have seen Doug Flutie, Dan Marino, Tony Eason, Teddy Bridgewater, Oliver Luck, Gino Torretta, Michael Vick, Sandy Schwab, Alex Van Pelt, Shane Matthews and of course Donovan McNabb, Todd Philcox, Marvin Graves and Donnie McPherson.

Who am I forgetting?
Expand...
I'm going to word this wrong but the best passer rating season a QB has ever had that played a game in the dome (Syracuse or opponent) is Boyd this year followed by Don McPherson in 87, then (obviously McPherson was better given the difference in eras, no comparison)

Believe it or not, the next best after that was Jake Kelchner WVU in 1993??? then Tyler Palko in 2006?? then McNabb in 1995. Bridgewater last year was probably next

here's the list of seasons, i might've missed a couple seasons with a dome game
http://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/leaders/pass-rating-player-season.html

that's just passer rating, I just thought it was interesting. Vick's passer rating in 2000 was really low, he's not even close to being on the list
 
Last edited:
Millhouse said:
I'm going to word this wrong but the best passer rating season a QB has ever had that played a game in the dome (Syracuse or opponent) is Boyd this year followed by Don McPherson in 87, then (obviously McPherson was better given the difference in eras, no comparison)

Believe it or not, the next best after that was Jake Kelchner WVU in 1993??? then Tyler Palko in 2006?? then McNabb in 1995. Bridgewater last year was probably next

here's the list of seasons, i might've missed a couple seasons with a dome game
http://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/leaders/pass-rating-player-season.html

that's just passer rating, I just thought it was interesting. Vick's passer rating in 2000 was really low, he's not even close to being on the list
Expand...

Ironically when Jake Kelchner played in the Dome in 1993, I'm not sure if they threw a pass since they ran for 500 yards.
 
no love for PeterTom Willis??

upperdeck's stats say brad johnson caught a pass in that game.....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
170,359
Messages
4,886,911
Members
5,996
Latest member
meierscreek

Share this page

Online statistics

Members online
225
Guests online
1,170
Total visitors
1,395
Totals may include hidden visitors.


...
Top Bottom