Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Alsacs, post: 819594, member: 652"] I thought the Heisman trophy was awarded annually to the most outstanding player in college football. Giving A.J. McCarron the Heisman is like the NFL MVP being awarded to Russell Wilson. While McCarron/Russell have good numbers neither of them would be worthy of the Heisman/MVP because of superior candidates. While I believe this alleged incident last December with Jameis Winston is why this is even debatable at this moment I can't believe the media is trying to drum up support for McCarron as if the Heisman is a lifetime achievement award. If I was ranking my top 5 QBs this season I wouldn't put McCarron in my top 5 and I am not even including about stat stuffers in Frenso State or Northern Illinois. [URL='http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootball/writer/tony-barnhart/24280322/five-lessons-we-learned-mccarron-williams-carey-are-heismanworthy'] http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootball/writer/tony-barnhart/24280322/five-lessons-we-learned-mccarron-williams-carey-are-heismanworthy[/URL] My top 5 College Football QBs this season 1. Jameis Winston 2. Marcus Mariotta 3. Aaron Murray 4. Johnny Manziel 5. Teddy Bridgewater 6. Bryce Petty 7. Braxton Miller 8. Zack Mettenberger 9. A.J. McCarron Now, has McCarron been one of the most successful modern college QBs of all-time? Hell yes, winning 2 NC titles and likely playing for 3rd is unbelivable, but don't tell me this kid is the reason why Alabama has won it has more to do with the fact Alabama has the most talented OL(4 1st rd NFL draft picks in the last 3 years), stacked RBs, and an awesome defense. Giving the Heisman to A.J. McCarron makes no sense when somebody like Miami's Ken Dorsey didn't win one and his Miami Hurricanes dominated college football from 2000-2002 like Alabama has recently. EDIT: LOL I forget to add Bryce Petty as well. [/QUOTE]

Verification: What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?