Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Libero2, post: 519238, member: 2812"] All other things being equal I would agree. But obviously not everything is equal across the landscape of college football. In other words if you gave an elite coaching staff (let's say Alabamas for the fun of it) and gave them a roster of 2/3 star guys, and pitted them against a novice coaching staff (let's say SUs new staff) which has a team of mostly 4/5 star guys with a few 3s sprinkled in, who are you betting on to win the game? What about which staff is likely to develop their players the best? I would still bet on the elite staff creating the best players 4 years down the line. But if everything is equal at the start, it's better to have better players out of the gate, no questions asked. [/QUOTE]