Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="RF2044, post: 1141498, member: 40"] We need to find a way to factor in rushing. Being a dual threat QB provides a different way of making positive gains than passing alone, but that "value" is not accounted for in any way in the rankings [I know that isn't what you were calculating here]. Would be interesting to what results that type of multi-dimensional comparison would yield [I imagine that McPherson, Graves, McNabb and probably even Philcox would still rate atop the ratings; Hunt would probably jump up the list right behind that group--and possibly Mason]. And I can't believe that Scharr rated that highly on either list--talk about an outlier relative to his performance. [/QUOTE]