Interesting take on the Big Ten's struggles... | Syracusefan.com

Interesting take on the Big Ten's struggles...

Scooch

Living Legend
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
18,323
Like
64,271
Just read this piece on the ailing Big Ten:

http://espn.go.com/college-football...-theories-big-ten-conference-poor-performance

Couple things that made me think of SU...

One of the key points was that money doesn't guarantee success. No conference banks more than the B1G, and yet they literally have no marquee teams at the moment. So while our ACC move fills our coffers, I'm not in lock-step with those who think it means we'll definitely be better down the road.

This other point caught my eye.

"It all starts," Tiller said, "with the recruiting issue."
The Big Ten's recruiting issue is a decreasing number of star prep players living close to its campuses. There are other factors -- population shifts to the south and the fact that southern high schools play spring football while their northern counterparts don't -- all of which increase the challenges for Big Ten programs.
"That's a theory," Delany said. "You've got to look at the results, and you've got to attribute it to something, but I'm not a demographer, nor am I a football coach."
Tiller was, for years, and he had to adjust to the changes, including mining the state of Texas for talent during his time at Purdue.
"As a young person growing up in Ohio, the Pennsylvania-Ohio ability to provide a lot of players for a lot of different teams was there," Tiller said. "Penn State, I don't think, ever had to leave the state, and if they did, they went into [New] Jersey. I can remember when Bo [Schembechler] and Woody [Hayes] were slugging it out, and Bo would come down to Ohio and get half a dozen really good players, and they'd go up to Michigan and be stars right away. I just don't know if that's true anymore.
"For a guy from the Midwest, it's painful. It's painfully obvious that they're not up to speed."

This clearly applies to our natural recruiting base as well: NY, NJ, New England, etc. The south and west is clearly churning out a ton more game-ready kids than the north and east. Unfortunately we have to play more teams that are rooted in the south and have easier access to these kids. But hopefully that also means we'll have better means of landing some of them.

I kno
 
Interesting article.

Weird part is, I didn't even realize the Big 10 was struggling. They don't seem to be having any trouble beating us.

Some of their problems will fix themselves. Urban Meyer will ensure Ohio State stays at the top of the college football food chain (on the field). I think Brady Hoke will also help Michigan get back up there more consistently, the RichRod experience just wasn't a good fit. Michigan State seems very content with Dantonio, but that means you better expect to win by running the ball and playing defense, not with the vertical passing game. Wisconsin seems to be suffering from the massive assistant coaching losses. I don't think Nebraska will ever be Tom Osborne's Nebraska again, much because of those demographics, and the style they played to get there isn't something that could easily be pulled off today. We all know Penn State's issues too well.

I think the league will always struggle against the SEC. Everyone will. They've won the last 75 national championships. But there's no reason that the league is starting to struggle against everyone not named Syracuse (even including the MAC). They have to fix that. If it's a down cycle, so be it, they should be able to get past it.
 
Until miami left for the ACC we were getting quality players out of florida, getting into the ACC opens up those grounds again.
 
The spring football thing blew my mind. I had no idea NYS didn't do it until this past spring, I think. In Connecticut we have spring football, how many other states don't?
 
The MW and the NE are behind in available talent. It would be nice if we had a Fla and NJ/PA guy on our staff. Instead we have 2 NYC/LI and 4 MW guys. IMO we need to fix that going forward. Especially being in the ACC.
 
The MW and the NE are behind in available talent. It would be nice if we had a Fla and NJ/PA guy on our staff. Instead we have 2 NYC/LI and 4 MW guys. IMO we need to fix that going forward. Especially being in the ACC.

Great post..not

Ignoring of course the two Guys on staff who recruited and continue to recruit Georgia, Florida and Tennessee, and Shafer who recruits and has recruited Florida..Other than those guys you are spot on...
 
Great post..not

Ignoring of course the two Guys on staff who recruited and continue to recruit Georgia, Florida and Tennessee, and Shafer who recruits and has recruited Florida..Other than those guys you are spot on...

Um did you refute anything I said? No you didn't. We have 4 guys whose main connections are in the MW. That IMO is three too many.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
172,413
Messages
5,017,394
Members
6,027
Latest member
Old Timer

Online statistics

Members online
225
Guests online
5,857
Total visitors
6,082


...
Top Bottom