Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="Irishsecra1, post: 5615601, member: 8453"]
Well if he wanted to keep his redshirt, which even Carney admitted to, he couldn’t be the man once Collins proved to be inadequate.
So, yeah, he had no interest in taking one for the team.
Some players would, he didn’t
That was always the original plan and he stuck to it.
Frans subsequent treatment of Carney is probably explained by that.
Harsh as it put Filardi and the whole team in an awful position.
no  clue why Beilein didn’t play at all either.

Honestly, it wasn’t up to Carney to save the team once Fran committed to his first year being a red shirt. Carney said multiple times the plan was to redshirt.
It wasn’t his fault Angeli got injured, Collins was a disaster and apparently Jakhari was injured.
Ideally, Fran should have given him Filardis first start. See how Carney does. After his third start, give him the option to keep playing or stop to preserve the redshirt.
If he decides to keep the redshirt, either go back to Collins or throw Filardi in the deep end.
We would not have been any worse off and Carney could show everyone what he could or couldn’t do.

Instead there is this big mystery about Carney and why he never truly played any meaningful minutes
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?