Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="721Comstock, post: 5294076, member: 5429"] You could, but you’d be wrong. McNabb is (nearly) undisputed #1. Maybe I’m biased because it was while I was at SU, but McPherson is my #2. Dude got jobbed outta the Heisman. Undefeated season. For all of his warts, Dungey had a better overall college career than Nassib, including a better final Senior year season. Yes - Ryan got drafted and got to hold Eli’s clipboard for a few seasons. But we’re talking Cuse college careers, not NFL - otherwise Philcox & Devito would be 2 & 3. LOL. And then there’s Graves. Who also had a better overall career & peak than Nassib. McCord has had an amazing one season. But that’s not enough for QB Rushmore status on its own, unless it leads to a championship of some sort. Call it the Carmelo Rule. :cool: [/QUOTE]