Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="retro44, post: 1649555, member: 587"] McNabb had a 9-7 playoff record,Kelly had a 9-8 playoff record. McNabb had a 85.6 career passing rating,Kelly had a 84.4 career passing rating. McNabb had 234 TD'S to 117 INT for a 2-1 ratio. Kelly had 237 TD'S to 175 INT. McNabb has an all time NFL player ranking of #319,Kelly's is #483. Phil Simms was the first person I can Remember on his radio show ask the the listeners which QB. numbers here were an NFL hall of fame member and who is the two he was talking about. This why I know I brought it up. He flat out said if Kelly is in the Hall so should McNabb be and Simms was a top NFL QB for a while.His opinion has a carries of weight. [/QUOTE]