Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Finwad32, post: 1649694, member: 651"] He won, won what? AFC Chips? McNabb went to 5 NFC Chips, was 1-4. Other than that, McNabb is on par or better in just about every category. You talk about McNabb puking, Kelly folded like a cheap suit constantly. How many games did he get carried off the field? His backup has the most memorable win of the two. Statistically, McNabb didn't play in that much different of an era, only 2 years separated them. Those rules didn't come into play until at the very least the tail end of McNabb's career. If the only other difference is 3 more Conf. Chips, I don't see how it's so cut and dry. McNabb's rushing ability and ranks should be commended as well. Both were great in their own way, in their own time. [/QUOTE]