Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Newhouser, post: 1651169, member: 5155"] football HOF is interesting in that they always let too many people in each year, yet each year you say "how did that guy get in over that guy". McNabb was a very good pro who carried a franchise to relevance while dealing with a poor personnel department and a big game challenged coach. Having said that if he went to BC nobody would think he was a HOFer. Numbers and stats are tough as eras change - watching him play he was never a good enough passer especially in big spots to put him in the elite category that should - repeat should - make up the HOF. Coughlin in. Freeny - maybe (he was more dominant at his position than Donovan was at his) McNabb - slim and fading Anderson - no [/QUOTE]