McCord

[Sdot]

Omg!!! Someone tell me what this means?!?

Means we will still find a way to get screwed and swear at the NCAA for it.

 

[sufan59]

Well this has been a day of CFB news

 

[bnoro]

Omg!!! Someone tell me what this means?!?

He played in JUCO and is saying that shouldn't count. Not really comparable with Kyle's situation.

 

[oldpinepoint]

I

He played in JUCO and is saying that shouldn't count. Not really comparable with Kyle's situation.

isnt He the dude who played 2 years at juco and now wants a fifth year. Basically saying juco yeats shouldn’t count

 

[RandomGuy]

He played in JUCO and is saying that shouldn't count. Not really comparable with Kyle's situation.

However.

Loss of a NIL year was part of the argument. I believe post NIL may have changed some things.

 

[Jake]

Omg!!! Someone tell me what this means?!?

I think it means we need to find a judge who is a Syracuse season ticket holder

 

[orange79]

He played in JUCO and is saying that shouldn't count. Not really comparable with Kyle's situation.

Good point. Just coming to post this. He played 2 years at New Mexico Military Institute (JUCO), 2 years at UNM, and one year at Vandy.

 

[NKR1978]

I think it means we need to find a judge who is a Syracuse season ticket holder

I argued that 30+ pages ago.

 

[RandomGuy]

One could easily argue, that Day's decision caused McCord irreparable harm .

From the ruling.

 

[FasterCuse]

Means we will still find a way to get screwed and swear at the NCAA for it.

I am not a lawyer, so maybe a lawyer can read the memo attached to this ruling and interpret it. I think the big thing that may come out of this is that the eligibility rules within the NCAA bylaws are now subject to the Sherman Act (anti-competive agreements) due to the new NIL landscape.

As others have mentioned this is different than Kyle’s case, but I’m sure a lawyer could make some argument on why denying Kyle (or anyone) a 5th year is anti-competitive in nature and goes against the Sherman Act.

 

[UpstateSM]

I think it means we need to find a judge who is a Syracuse season ticket holder

My bus driver/mother is a town justice.

I'll have my paralegals (myself) spend the night finding some case law that'll give her jurisdiction over the NCAA.

 

[Jake]

My bus driver/mother is a town justice.

I'll have my paralegals (myself) spend the night finding some case law that'll give her jurisdiction over the NCAA.

There is a reality show in your future my friend.

 

[HRE Otto IV]

I am not a lawyer, so maybe a lawyer can read the memo attached to this ruling and interpret it. I think the big thing that may come out of this is that the eligibility rules within the NCAA bylaws are now subject to the Sherman Act (anti-competive agreements) due to the new NIL landscape.

As others have mentioned this is different than Kyle’s case, but I’m sure a lawyer could make some argument on why denying Kyle (or anyone) a 5th year is anti-competitive in nature and goes against the Sherman Act.

If this is allowed you will have kids staying 10 years.

 

[NKR1978]

I am not a lawyer, so maybe a lawyer can read the memo attached to this ruling and interpret it. I think the big thing that may come out of this is that the eligibility rules within the NCAA bylaws are now subject to the Sherman Act (anti-competive agreements) due to the new NIL landscape.

As others have mentioned this is different than Kyle’s case, but I’m sure a lawyer could make some argument on why denying Kyle (or anyone) a 5th year is anti-competitive in nature and goes against the Sherman Act.

I don't believe the differences are relevant to the conclusion. You have guys getting 6 years or 8 years of eligibility, and Kyle would be shut out for a few minutes of garbage time of one extra game?

That's how I would frame it.

 

[vegasnick]

He played in JUCO and is saying that shouldn't count. Not really comparable with Kyle's situation.

Why are you so adamant? This most certainly helps Kyle's case- again it shows the NCAA is basically rubber stamping EVERYTHING! Not too mention the signing of Rickie Collins only shows that door for Kyle is still wide open.

 

[Nick44]

Doritosguy in a rout.

Dude had ONE post, and spawned a zillion replies.

(He did - eventually - post a 2nd time.
In response to one of *my* posts.
You’re welcome!)

Dammit. Doritosguy is a great name. I wish I had thought of that 10 years ago.

 

[Marroniac]

Prediction:
1) NCAA grants McCord a 5th year.
2) Dart gets another year of eligibility somehow and transfers to be our backup. Because, D.A.R.T.
3) We win the whole damn thing.
4) NCAA retroactively declares McCord ineligible and revokes our Championship.
5) Autry gets a 5 year extension.

 

[721Comstock]

Prediction:
1) NCAA grants McCord a 5th year.
2) Dart gets another year of eligibility somehow and transfers to be our backup. Because, D.A.R.T.
3) We win the whole damn thing.
4) NCAA retroactively declares McCord ineligible and revokes our Championship.
5) Autry gets a 5 year extension.

I kinda think I’d sign up for that?

Would rather have the Natty,
and have the stupid NCAA try to pretend it never happened,
than not have it at all.

It’s the reverse-Fabricio Melo rule.

 

[RandomGuy]

If I understand correctly, Day sent in on the waiver, saying he shouldn't have played Kyle. With NIL, this would seem a simple case of irreparable harm. They didn't know then...

Kyle's damages could easily be quantified, BUT who pays them? OSU, NCAA? Well. NOONE cuz, they say screw it and give him the extra year. MAKE IT SO!

 

[OrangeFreek]

He played in JUCO and is saying that shouldn't count. Not really comparable with Kyle's situation.

bnoro can you please just be a Optimus for a little bit…. PLEASE!!!!! Darn you!!! UGH!!!!! WHY???????????? Let us dream a little longer you jerk!! Lol. JK about the jerk part….. maybe…. I don’t know….

 

[anomander]

So if you were coach, how would you explain to your number 2 that despite him working his way up the depth chart, you were going to play the guy he beat out? Would you tell him it’s because you have a crystal ball and saw him years and another team later setting records, and he may need to stay on the bench due to the potential?

#2 would say thanks for preserving my redshirt?

 

[mustacheovich]

 

[bnoro]

Why are you so adamant? This most certainly helps Kyle's case- again it shows the NCAA is basically rubber stamping EVERYTHING! Not too mention the signing of Rickie Collins only shows that door for Kyle is still wide open.

How does it helps Kyle's case? Pavia was literally arguing that his two years of JUCO should not count towards his eligibility.

"The NCAA is rubber stamping everything"? He had to get a court injunction and the NCAA hasn't rubber stamped anything.

 

[djorange1989]

Why are you so adamant? This most certainly helps Kyle's case- again it shows the NCAA is basically rubber stamping EVERYTHING! Not too mention the signing of Rickie Collins only shows that door for Kyle is still wide open.

The NCAA didn’t rubber stamp this, Pavia sued the NCAA and received a court ordered injunction. If Kyle loses his appeal, will he sue or will he leave? Should I Sue or Should I Go Now?

 

[anomander]

How does it helps Kyle's case? Pavia was literally arguing that his two years of JUCO should not count towards his eligibility.

"The NCAA is rubber stamping everything"? He had to get a court injunction and the NCAA hasn't rubber stamped anything.

Why would playing 2 years of JUCO not counts towards his eligibility?