Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="CU44SE, post: 645697, member: 2196"]
Got to remember, people have discussed Warner at length, and people aren't even sure that he is HOF worthy.  Those years at the end of his Rams tenure where he was injured weren't to good and then he went to the Giants and was awful.  Look at his stats, he had 3 great years in St Louis before only playing 9 games in 2 years with a total of 4 td and 12 int.  Then he went to the giants and played 10 games throwing 6 td and 4 picks.  He then went to the cardinals and it wasn't until his third year where he started to play well.  His first two years he played a total of 16 games, with 3,100 yards, 17 td, and 14 picks.  His last three years were pretty solid, but I don't see that as HOF worthy. The HOF is for transcendent players, and as much as I love McNabb, I don't think his chances are very good.  He ultimately will be graded against Brady, Manning, and Favre.  Those are transcendent players.  I bleed Orange, but if he didnt graduate and lead Syracuse like he did this wouldn't even be a discussion.  I know he didnt have great receivers, but its eye opening that he never had a 4,000 yard season in a passing offense.  Also I know QB rating is not a great, but it is generally a good indicator of a QB.  McNabb was over 100 once in 13 years, and had a career average of 85.6.  Even Warner, with all those bad years had an average QB rating of 93.7 over 12 years.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?