Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="Melancer46, post: 3903140, member: 1674"]
Obviously the comparison isn't quite apples to apples but just some resume comparisons for some of the other PGs:

Oscar Robertson
[LIST]
[*]9 1st team All-NBA
[*]2 2nd team All-NBA
[*]1 MVP
[*]1 MVP runner up
[*]7 other top 5 MVP finishes
[*]12 All Stars
[/LIST]
Isiah:
[LIST]
[*]3 1st team All-NBA
[*]2 2nd team All-NBA
[*]1 Finals MVP
[*]1 5th place MVP finish
[*]12 All Stars
[/LIST]
CP3:
[LIST]
[*]4 1st team All-NBA
[*]5 2nd team All-NBA
[*]1 3rd team All-NBA
[*]1 MVP runner-up
[*]4 other top 5 MVP finishes
[*]11 All Stars
[/LIST]
Steve Nash:
[LIST]
[*]3 1st team All-NBA
[*]2 2nd team All-NBA
[*]2 3rd team All-NBA
[*]2 MVPs
[*]1 MVP runner-up
[*]8 All Stars
[/LIST]
John Stockton:
[LIST]
[*]2 1st team All-NBA
[*]6 2nd team All-NBA
[*]3 3rd team All-NBA
[*]0 top 5 MVP finishes
[*]10 All Stars (more All-NBAs than All Stars lol)
[/LIST]
Jason Kidd:
[LIST]
[*]5 1st team All-NBA
[*]1 2nd team All-NBA
[*]1 MVP runner-up
[*]1 5th place MVP finish
[*]10 All Stars
[/LIST]
I think Oscar is pretty clearly the #2 or #3 PG all-time. I'd go with CP3 after that, and then it's a debate between Nash and Isiah IMO for #5.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?