Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Knicks411, post: 3910026, member: 767"] Peak Shaq was absurd. But it was a relatively short peak. This isn't the only way to consider the issue, but if you knew everything about how their careers would pan out, would you pick a rookie Duncan or Shaq? Obviously not the results of the team, which would depend on the rest of the roster, but the player itself; I think I would rather take Duncan because you know you're getting a legendary player for like 15 years. With Shaq you get a 5 year period where he's maybe the most dominant ever and you need to try hard not to win a title. So I can def see the pro Shaq case [/QUOTE]