Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="jncuse, post: 2454424, member: 1969"] Not against the rule (if it is with a larger group of free transfer rules) , but if this is the only rule you implement, you actually kill parity and competition by handing out a few death penalties each year to over performing mid majors and lower tier P5 programs. It will only help the top 20 programs. Who are the schools with good players that were under-recruited? Solid mid majors and lower tier P5's. The schools that are most vulnerable to a coach moving upward. Not only does the coach leave, but they lose all their decent players. They lose players, and can't replenish with other transfers immediately. It's a death penalty. I am for fairness, but I don't think people are really thinking how terrible the consequences are if this is the only pool of "Free agents" created. [/QUOTE]