Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="Alsacs, post: 2649391, member: 652"]
I don’t think Eli is a HOFer because I believe it is the best of the best.
It should be exclusive for the best players of each generation.
I don’t think Eli has ever been close to the best of the best. He is the Hall of Very good.

Tuck was better at his position for multiple seasons than Eli ever was.
QBs get credit for winning but they also get blame for failing.
Plus Eli’s INT numbers are crazy.
He shouldn’t get in when the fans numbers aren’t 75%+ then they aren’t a HOFer they are just good.

I wouldn’t put either Rivers or Eli in the HOF this ERA is completely different from the 1970s thru 1990s.

Eli is 12 games over .500 for his career. Give me a break.

The active QBs who should be HOFers.
Brady
Rodgers
Brees
Rothlisberger

Russell Wilson if he continues.

The Joe Flacco comp isn’t going away.

Eli is a career 119-107 QB 226 games played.
Flacco is 102-67 QB 169 games played.
Eli has 2 SBs
Flacco has 1 SB.

Eli in playoffs 8-4 record
Flacco in playoffs 10-5 record.

Flacco gets another SB they are even and Flacco is way better.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?