Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="chugg21, post: 2652804, member: 3360"] I'm with ya on this. Alex Smith was clearly better last year. Being 3 years younger as they start to age out and being in that Andy Reid offense probably has a lot to do with it though. That ESPN QB tiers thing has Smith at 16 and Eli at 17 so kind of arguing something that probably has more to do with what is around them than what they actually are at this point. Eli behind that horrific O-Line, with no running game and w/o OBJ didn't really stand much of a chance at doing anything. Smith with Hunt, Kelce and Hill was provided a way better opportunity for success. Given that, if I had to pick 1 to win games with this year regardless of situation I'm taking Smith with 0 hesitation. [/QUOTE]