Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Forza Azzurri, post: 3602615, member: 1452"] Sorry. My post was not clear in terms of what I was asking. There are only two Giants jerseys in my Man Cave - Simms and LT. No Bavaro, no Eli, No Banks, No Pepper, No Strahan. Really high bar. Simms was an absolutely phenomenal QB who, if the offense needed to play a bigger role for those great Giants teams, would be in the HOF. I only put them in the same sentence because I viewed them as game managers, a responsibility imposed on them from above. What I don't know is how good McMahon really was. Was he a really good QB that had to play the game manager role or was he more Trent Dilferish? [/QUOTE]