Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Eric15, post: 3444695, member: 676"] These are all fair thoughts. The answer is: I don't know how they would have fared if the roles were reversed. I'm just looking at their overall record and body of work and who they beat, and I think Coach P is ahead (by a slight margin). And Coach P was intimately involved with that rebuild as Mac's top assistant/recruiter -- he didn't just walk into the situation from another school. One argument in favor of P is that he generally had to deal with more difficult schedules than Mac. In 1988 for example we didn't play a single team that finished that season with a winning record until WVU at the end of the year. [/QUOTE]