Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="Ghost, post: 187548, member: 581"]
And yet Rivers is undefeated against Eli.  Since QB's are pretty much all that factor into these games, I guess that means he's better than Eli.  :)
 
These whole arguments are Eli-fan boy based so they're not really winnable.    It's not like Eli made that Williams dude fumble over the game to the Giants in the Conference Championship - if he did that, then he would be elite.  :)
 
Analysis doesn't begin and end with the Super Bowl - if it did Brad Johnson would forever be remembered as a super awesome almost HOF worthy QB.  Match-ups matter, leagues matter, defenses, all of it.   Plus, unless someone does something special and sets a record QB's win MVP by default typically.  I don't know, if Welker makes that catch, or Tyree drops his it wouldn't mean Eli sucks either.  Although maybe he would to Giants fan - who knows.
 
I sincerely doubt you could more than a handful of non-Giants fan who think Eli is in the same ballpark as Rogers as a QB.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?