Player ratings week 4

[moqui]

Every Monday (or Tuesday if there is a Monday game), posters will be asked to rank the scholarship players in order, using whatever metric you want. Some will base it on total season production, some just on the most recent games, some on a combination, some on a metric of their own creation.

The only rules are that you must list at least 5 players, and you must list them in order - no ties. Force yourself to order them. I know it is hard; some weeks there will be very little difference between #3 and #7. If you do write "Player A and Player B tie" then I will rank Player A ahead because you wrote his name first.

This week's vote will be open until Friday

Here are the results for Week 3

 

[jordoo]

MCW
CJ
Brandon
ROk
James
DC2
Cooney
Grant
Keita

 

[Gabjon]

Tough week

MCW
CJ
Brandon
Keita
Grant
James
Cooney
Xmas
DC2

 

[br801]

1. MCW
2. Southy
3. BT
4. CJ
5. Keita
6. Xmas
7. DC2
8. Cooney
9. Grant

 

[jekelish]

1. MCW
2. Triche
3. Fair
4. Dirty
5. Grant
6. BMK
7. Rak
8. Cooney
9. DC2

It's getting to the point where it is increasingly difficult to rank 5-9. They are just so interchangeable. I don't think DC2 is the 9th most valuable guy, but I just at this point think the other guys have been a little better.

 

[moqui]

It's getting to the point where it is increasingly difficult to rank 5-9. They are just so interchangeable. I don't think DC2 is the 9th most valuable guy, but I just at this point think the other guys have been a little better.

people ask whether once again we have the best 6th man in the nation, but I think that - regardless of how you shuffle the deck - we probably have the best 9th man in the country!

 

[jordoo]

1. MCW

It's getting to the point where it is increasingly difficult to rank 5-9. They are just so interchangeable. I don't think DC2 is the 9th most valuable guy, but I just at this point think the other guys have been a little better.

No doubt, its pretty hard tpo pick the order down the line but Like moqui said b
est 9th man so not a bad thing for whoever sits in taht spot.

 

[AirForceOrange]

1. MCW
2. Triche
3. Fair
4. Dirty
5. Grant
6. BMK
7. Rak
8. Cooney
9. DC2

It's getting to the point where it is increasingly difficult to rank 5-9. They are just so interchangeable. I don't think DC2 is the 9th most valuable guy, but I just at this point think the other guys have been a little better.

Same for me please...

 

[MikeSU02]

1. MCW
2. Fair
3. BT
4. Dirty
5. Grant
6. Rak
7. BMK
8. DC2
9. Cooney

 

[moqui]

1. MCW
2. Dirty
3. Big Time
4. CJ
5. Rak
6. Moose
7. DC2
8. JG
9. TC

 

[pfister1]

1. MCW steals the honors this week
2. Brandon
3. Fair
4. Dirty
5. Cooney
6. Grant
7. DC II
8. Rak
9. Keita

and I mean no disrespect by putting Keita last, more a reflection on everyone else having a pretty good week.

 

[ar inj]

1. MCW


2. Brandon
3. CJ
4. James

5. Keita 6. RAK 7. DC2
8 Cooney
9. Grant​

 

[Hoov50]

1 MCW
2 Fair
3 Triche
4 Southerland
5 DC2
6 Keita
7 Christmas
8 Grant
9 Cooney

 

[General20]

Its hard to change someone's position based on the games that were played this past week, but I am going to bump MCW up a spot because he's hitting jump shots.

1. Carter-Williams
2. Southerland
3. Triche
4. Fair
5. Christmas
6. Cooney
7. Keita
8. Coleman
9. Grant

 

[RF2044]

MCW
CJ
Brandon
Cooney
James
DC2

Rak
Grant
Keita

Moqui, I'm basing my assessments this year on weekly performance--not amalgamating year to date.

 

[UnderHisOwnPower]

[/quote]


MCW
Triche
Carl Jr
Southerland
Rak
JG
DC2
BMK
Cooney

 

[BlackKnight76]

MCW
Triche
CJ
JG
Rak
Cooney
James
BMK
DC2

 

[Madbiker]

MCW
CJ Fair
Triche
Cooney
Grant
Southerland
DC2
Rak
BMK

 

[SteveC]

MCW
CJ
Brandon

Grant
Cooney
James
Rak
DC2
Keita

 

[Banned]

1. MCW
2. Southerland
3. Fair
4. Triche
5. Christmas
6. Keita
7. Coleman
8. Cooney
9. Grant

Absolutely no shame in being #9 right now. Loving this team right now.

 

[CuseinNYC]

MCW
CJ
Triche
JS
Rak
Grant
DJC
BMK
Cooney

 

[JOC44]

1. Carter-Williams
2. Fair
3. Southerland
4. Keita
5. Triche
6. Grant
7. Christmas
8. Coleman
9. Cooney

 

[moqui]

BTTT

only 19 votes so far . . . had 29 last week and 34 the week before

 

[CuseGrad94]

Mcw
CJ
BT
Dirty
MooMoo25
Rak
Cooney
BMK
DC2



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[arbitragegls]

MCW
Triche
CJ
Cooney
Grant
Coleman
Keita
Christmas