Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="Crusty, post: 2550834, member: 2265"]
This thread just got very interesting.

Dungey and Nassib, one pro style and one dual threat - impossible to compare.  Both highly intelligent competitive leaders - but that's where the similarities end.

I will ignore running comparisons for obvious reasons.

As passers, I think Nasib has the edge in short to intermediate passes with Dungey far better downfield. I also think Dungey has more touch.

As field generals they are both good with Nassib being more patient and Dungey more explosive.

Nassib had the far better OLine, but not as talented a group of receivers as ED. Nassib played in a more conventional offense. (Interesting to speculate what his numbers would have been had he played in Dino's. I think they might has been off the charts.)

Nassib had a winning record in a weaker conference while Dungey's W-L record is poor in the tougher ACC.

Last but not least, Nassib was indestructible and not reckless. He was always available while ED has not been. To me, that might be the tie-breaker.

I would take either anywhere anytime, but if I had to choose only one for a game it would be Dungey.  For a season, it would be Nassib.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?