Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="HRE Otto IV, post: 5304635, member: 5685"]
On 2nd thought, I think because of his NFL career and his involvement with SU after playing, McNabb does deserve it.

The problem with any add is how do you also not add X. There needs to be a separation. McNabb's play was legendary. But to the younger generation so was Dungey. What about Graves who led more successful teams than McNabb and had more career passing yards? Or McPherson? How do you separate these guys?

Non QBs we have NFL HoFers in Freeney, Ringo, Csonka, Mackey, Monk, Harrison. Are we adding all of them? Heck Mackey has an award named after him. What about Joe or Reyes who have all of our rushing records? Rob Moore? Tim Green? Chandler Jones? Gary Anderson? Coach P?

Same with BBall. How do you separate Melo from GMac and Hak? DC and Owens? Wallace who single handedly took us to a title game?

Melo did have the NBA and the Melo Center so I suppose you can use that to add him and not the others.

Edit

Also part of the problem is we have two sports in the same stadium/arena. Makes it even harder to add to the ring. If it was just a football stadium or just a BBall arena you could be more lenient.

Edit II

I forgot you also have Lax. So you also have the Gaits and Powells. There isn't enough room for everybody.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?