Runs and Bases: the 1900's, Part 2 | Syracusefan.com

Runs and Bases: the 1900's, Part 2

SWC75

Bored Historian
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
33,966
Like
65,504
TAKE ME OUT TO THE BALL PARK

In 1905 John McGraw and his owner, John T. Brush, allowed the Giants to play in the World Series against Connie Mack’s Philadelphia Athletics. The Giants won in five games with Christy Mathewson throwing three shut-outs. It was the first of 89 annual World Series. Even World Wars couldn’t stop them, (it took a strike to do that).

The same You-Tube poster who did posts on the 1903 World Series has done similar series on the 1905 World Series:

Administratively the game was set for the next half century with 8 teams in each league. There would be one brief challenge to that in the next decade but other than that fans now had a chance to develop loyalties that that could last for generations. What the game needed was places to watch the game that would last for generations. For years, baseball stadiums had been made primarily of wood. They were hastily constructed and sometimes came down just as hastily. Either they had structural weaknesses or were vulnerable to fire, (St. Louis once had 6 stadium fires in a 10 year period) or the team just left for something bigger and better.

The first stadium built to be more permanent was the Baker Bowl, in Philadelphia, which was made of steel and brick. The Phillies played there from 1895-1938. That didn’t produce a building boom at the time. But by the end of the first decade of the new century, baseball owners, (who had also achieved a sense of stability) were ready to build the first generation of famous baseball parks.

First up were the Philadelphia Athletics, co-owned by Ben Shibe, a maker of baseballs and field manager Connie Mack. They built Shibe Park, the first baseball stadium made of steel reinforced concrete. Opening day was April 12, 1909. The “design for the Shibe façade was in the ornate French Renaissance style, including arches, vaultings, and Ionic pilasters. The grandstand walls were to be of red brick and terra cotta and featured elaborate decorative friezes with baseball motifs, while cartouches framed the Athletics' "A" logo at regular intervals above the entrances. “ The fans must have been in awe. So were the other owners.

Two days later the St. Louis Browns opened a new Sportman’s Park, the third park by that name on that site but the first steel and concrete one. The Cardinals had previously played in the first Sportsman’s Park but were now playing at Robison Field, (named after their owner, as so many of these places were), which became the last of the old wooden ballparks until the Cardinals became the tenants of the Browns in the new Sportsman’s Park in 1920. The Cardinals became the more famous and successful team but the stadium was still owned by the Browns until they left town after the 1953 season.

In Pittsburgh, Barney Dreyfuss opened Forbes Field, (this one named after the British officer who had named Fort Pitt after a British Prime Minister back in the French and Indian War days) on 6/30/09. It was a large, beautiful park located next to the University of Pittsburgh and Schenley Park In 1937, the University of Pittsburgh opened the 42 story, 535 foot Cathedral of learning that dominated the view over the left field grandstand:
http://www.forbesfieldforever.com/gallery/forbes3.gif

It’s from the observation deck of the Cathedral that this famous image was taken the moment Bill Mazeroski hit the home run that won the 1960 World Series
http://31.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lk2xq3Eh821qjqin2o1_1280.jpg

In Cleveland the Naps tore down old wooden League Park and opened a new concrete and steel League Park on 4/21/10. It would be called Dunn Field from 1916-27 after the team’s owner at that time. But Charley Comiskey topped that on July 1st when he opened “The Baseball Palace of the World”, which was called White Sox Park, in Chicago. He held off his ego for three years before renaming it Comiskey Park.

The two new stadiums of 1911 were the direct result of fires. First American League Park, (also known as “Boundary Field”) in Washington burned down on March 17, 1911 and then New York’s Polo Grounds on April 12. In Washington, “Day and night the chanting of the Negro laborers has been heard in the vicinity, like Aladdin’s palace, the structure rose as if by magic.” (This was the same park where years later, Redskins owner George Preston Marshall refused to employ black players) Somehow they got a semblance of a park ready for opening day, the very day that President William Howard Taft started the tradition of the chief executive throwing out the first ball of the season. The new stadium was called “Nationals Park”, because the Senators were often called that in the papers. In 1920, it was changed to Griffith Stadium, after, of course, the owner of the team, Clark Griffith.

In New York, the New York Highlanders were kind enough to let the Giants play games at Hilltop Park until a new Polo Grounds could be made ready. It opened on June 28th, not completed but usable nonetheless. Two years later the Giants returned the favor by allowing the Yankees to become their tenants, which they were for ten years until Yankee Stadium opened.

The big news in 1912 was the sinking of the Titanic on April 15th. The big news in baseball was the three new ball parks that opened the season.

The Cincinnati Reds had been playing in something called “The Palace of the Fans”, which was full of ornate architecture, including Cornithian Columns and “Opera Boxes” that were the first luxury suites complete with waiters. It also had stalls for carriages under the grandstand. They were trying to draw the wealthy crowd to the ball park. But the Palace of the Fans didn’t have enough room for fans in it- only about 6,000. So it was torn down and replaced, on the same site by “Redland Field”, which would later be named Crosley Field after Powell Crosley who bought the franchise in the 1930’s.

In Boston, where the news of the Titanic hit hard due to the man Irish immigrants on board, Mayor John . “Honey Fitz” Fitzgerald, maternal grandfather of JFK, threw out the first ball at Fenway Park on April 20th. On the same day Navin Field in Detroit, built on the grounds of Charley Bennett’s old Field, opened. It was named after owner Frank Navin. The names changed to Briggs Stadium after Navin died in 1936 and Walter Briggs took over. It became Tiger Stadium in 1961.

Only one new park opened in 1913 but it was a memorable one. Charles Ebbetts, who had risen from the Dodger’s bookkeeper their owner, had purchased a lot called “pigtown” because of its former residents and built a baseball park which he, of course, named after himself. It became the iconic home of the beloved Brooklyn Dodgers, who, long before their great success were known as the “daffiness boys”. That could perhaps be anticipated on opening day when nobody could find the flag to be raised or the key to the bleachers. Ebbets had also forgotten to build a press box, a rather poor public relation move. But the “Cathedral of the Underdog” survived until 1957.

Another iconic ballpark was built in 1914 but you could tell by the name or the tenant. Charles Weeghman, who had made a fortune on early vending machines, couldn’t buy a major league club so he became one of the founders of the Federal League and put a team in Chicago called the “Whales”, (there are Whales in Chicago?). He built a ball park on the north side called Weeghman Park. When the Federal League disbanded in 1916, Weeghman was allowed to buy a majority interest in the Chicago Cubs and basically emerged that team with his Whales, (which allowed them to win the 1918 pennants, the only Cubs pennant between 1910 and 1929). The combined team played in Weeghman Park. But Weeghman suffered some financial setbacks and had to sell the team and the park to chewing gum magnate William Wrigley Jr., who then named the park after himself. It’s probably just as well because Weeghman was a major financial backer of the Klu Klux Clan. Besides, Weeghman Park just doesn’t have the same ring to it.

The final act in this ballpark building boom was Braves Field, which opened on August 18, 1915. Braves owner James Gaffney loved inside the park home runs. He thought hitting the ball over the fence was cheap, crude way to circle the bases. His new park went 402 feet down the left field line, the same to left center, 550 to deepest center, 402 in right center and 402 down the right field line. Ty Cobb paid a visit while in town to play the Red Sox and predicted “Nobody will ever hit a home run here!” meaning outside the park, of course. And no one did for ten years, until Giants catcher, Frank “Pancho” Snyder hit one 20 feet over the left field wall and 15 feet from the foul line. Gaffney’s insistence that his team play dead-ball era baseball in the live ball era condemned the once powerful franchise to the second division for decades afterwards.

But all these parks were originally built for the Dead Ball Era. They tended to have enormous distances to center field but also often very close journeys to right or left field became these were downtown ballparks built to conform to city blocks. When the Live Ball Era, (really the Babe Ruth Era- but more on that later) began, efforts were made to adapt these parks to the new, “longer” game. Large screens were put up to increase the height of short fences, especially in the Baker Bowl, Shibe Park, League Park, Ebbets Field and, most famously Fenway Park. These structures would be made of different materials at different points, (cement, tin, even chicken wire) and often have metal supports that were in play. The one in Ebbets field was concave. You never knew where the ball would bounce or how far. Huge scoreboards became a trend in the 30’s. The one in Ebbets extended 5 feet out onto the playing field.

Other parks had various quirks. The new Polo Grounds looked like a bathtub, if the drain is imagined as home plate. It was 505 feet to deepest center field but only 279 and 257 down the lines, a pull hitter’s paradise, (and there never was a pull hitter like Mel Ott who hit 323 of his 511 home runs there). There really were right and left field corners but they were 440 feet away, so far that open bullpens were placed there and were in play. Boston and Cincinnati were famous for using inclines instead of warning tracks at their outfield fences. The one in Cincinnati was apt to be muddy, (during a 1937 flood two Reds pitchers, urged on by photographers, rowed a boat over a submerged outfield fence). Babe Ruth in one of his last games, slipped on the incline and fell flat on his face, perhaps hastening his retirement. In Boston a minor leaguer named Smead Jolley was called up. His teammates gave him pointers on how to run up the incline to catch a ball. He did so but failed to get to the ball, which bounced back down the incline. Jolley chugged after it but fell down coming down the incline. When he got back to the dugout, he told his new teammates “Youse Guys taught me to run up the hill but you forgot to tell me how to run down it!”

But the biggest thing about the new stadiums is that they were big. Here is a chart showing the names and capacity of their predecessors and the initial and eventual capacity of the new stadium:

Boston
Red Sox: Hunting Avenue Grounds 9,000; Fenway Park 27, 000/37,500
Braves: South End Grounds 11,000; Braves Field 38,000/46,000
New York
Dodgers: Washington Park 18,800; Ebbets Field 18,000/35,000
Yankees: Hilltop Park 15,000; New Polo Grounds 16,000/56,000 and Yankee Stadium 58,000/ 71.700
Giants: Old Polo Grounds 16,000; New Polo Grounds 16,000/56,000
Philadelphia
Phillies: Baker Bowl 18,000/20,000
Athletics: Columbia Park 13,600; Shibe Park 20,000/33,500
Washington
Senators: American League Park 6,500: Griffith Stadium 32,000/35,000
Pittsburgh
Pirates: Exposition Park 16,000; Forbes Field 23,000/41,000
Detroit
Tigers: Bennett Field 14,000; Tiger Stadium 23,000/54,226
Cleveland
Indians: Old League Park 9,000; New league Park 21,000/22,500
Cincinnati
Reds: Palace of the Fans 6,000; Crosley Field 25,000/33,000
Chicago
Cubs: West Side Grounds 16,000; Wrigley Field 14,000/40,000
White Sox: South Side Park 15,000; Comiskey Park 28,800/ 52,000
St. Louis
Browns: Old Sportman’s Park 18,000; New Sportsman’s Park 17,600/34,500
Cardinals: Robson Field 21,000; New Sportsman’s Park 17,600/34,500

Baseball was becoming big-time- both as a sport and as a business.

The new stadiums served baseball fans for an average of 61 years, (counting Fenway and Wrigley, which are still going strong). If a father decided to take his young son to every ballpark in the majors in 1923 to see every team play a home game they would have seen the Red Sox in Fenway, the Braves in Braves Field, the Dodgers in Ebbets Field, the Giants in the Polo Grounds, the Yankees in Yankees Stadium, the Phillies in the Baker Bowl, the Athletics in Shibe Park, the Senators in Griffith Stadium, the Pirates in Forbes Field, the Tigers in Navin Field, the Indians in league Park, the Red sin Redland Field, the Cubs in Wrigley, the White Sox in Comiskey and the Cardinals and Browns in Sportsman’s Park . If the son had done the same thing with his son in 1952, the only changes they would have seen were that the Phillies were now sharing Shibe Park with the A’s, the Indians have moved over to Municipal Stadium and the parks in Detroit and Cincinnati had changed their names. If that fellow’s young son had done the same thing 29 years later, in 1981 with his son, they would have travelled to see 26 teams in 26 different ballparks, including 16 cities that had no major league teams in 1952. The only ballparks that would have been the same would have been Fenway, Yankee Stadium, (although many consider that a second Yankee Stadium after the extensive renovations of 1974-75), Tiger Stadium, Wrigley Field and Comiskey. And, if that kid had grown up to do the same thing with his son in 2010, only Fenway and Wrigley would be left. Baseball has never been so stable as it was in the 20’s, 30’s and 40’s. And the groundwork for that stability was laid in the first two decades of the century

Sources:
The Ballpark Book by Ron Smith
Diamonds by Michael Gershman
Green Cathedrals by Philip J. Lowry
Lost Ballparks by Lawrence S. Ritter
Take Me Out to the Ballpark by Lowell Reidenbaugh
And Internet sources, including Wikipedia and Baseballrefence.com
 
RUNS AND BASES

This was the period Honus Wagner made a serious run at Cap Anson’s all-time standing. He caught him in bases and nearly so in runs. But he still had eight seasons to go to do that. He led in run production ever year of this period and four times in five years for base production. Baseball had never seen such a dominant player. Anson was a great player for a long time but he never dominated the standings as Wagner did. But another player was beginning to dominate the American League: Ty Cobb

1905- National League

Runs Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 209
Cy Seymour CIN 208
Mike Donlin NY 197
Sherry Magee PHI 193
John Titus PHI 186
Sam Mertes NY 184
Shad Barry CIN 165
Frank Chance CHI 160
Dan McGann NY 158
Miller Huggins CIN 154

Bases Produced
Cy Seymour CIN 397
Mike Donlin NY 389
Honus Wagner PIT 388
Sherry Magee PHI 345
Sam Mertes NY 338
John Titus PHI 319
Roy Thomas PHI 317
Miller Huggins CIN 314
Jimmy Slagle CHI 304
Bill Maloney CHI 298

1905- American League

Runs Produced
Harry Davis PHI 168
Lave Cross PHI 146
Jiggs Donahue CHI 146
Sam Crawford DET 142
Danny Murphy PHI 136
Elmer Flick CLE 132
Charlie Hickman WAS 131
George Davis CHI 128
Danny Hoffman PHI 127
Jimmy Collins BOS 127

Bases Produced
Topsy Hartsel PHI 344
Harry Davis PHI 335
George Stone STL 329
Elmer Flick CLE 319
Sam Crawford DET 319
Fielder Jones CHI 279
George Davis CHI 278
Jesse Burkett BOS 277
Harry Bay CLE 276
Danny Murphy PHI 274

1906- National League

Runs Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 172
Frank Chance CHI 171
Jim Nealon PIT 162
Harry Steinfeldt CHI 161
Cy Seymour CIN 142
Art Devlin NY 139
Joe Tinker CHI 138
Sherry Magee PHI 138
Jimmy Sheckard CHI 134
Tim Jordan BRO 133

Bases Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 348
Sherry Magee PHI 336
Frank Chance CHI 331
Art Devlin NY 322
Harry Lumley BRO 314
Harry Steinfeldt CHI 308
Miller Huggins CIN 296
Jimmy Sheckard CHI 291
Cy Seymour CIN 289
Frank Schulte CHI 279

1906- American League

Runs Produced
Nap Lajoie CLE 179
Harry Davis PHI 178
Hal Chase NY 160
Elmer Flick CLE 159
George Stone STL 156
Charlie Hemphill STL 146
Terry Turner CLE 145
George Davis CHI 143
Jimmy Williams NY 135
Sam Crawford DET 135

Bases Produced
George Stone STL 378
Elmer Flick CLE 368
Nap Lajoie 339
Harry Davis PHI 325
Charlie Hemphill STL 300
Topsy Hartsel PHI 297
Sam Crawford DET 291
Terry Turner CLE 279
Chick Stahl BOS 278
Hal Chase NY 277

1907- National League

Runs Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 174
Sherry Magee PHI 156
Fred Clarke PIT 154
Ed Abbaticchio PIT 143
Tommy Leach PIT 141
Spike Shannon NY 136
John Titus PHI 132
Ginger Beaumont BOS 125
John Ganzel CIN 123
Harry Steinfeldt CHI 121

Bases Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 371
Sherry Magee PHI 328
Ginger Beaumont BOS 308
Tommy Leach PIT 304
Fred Clarke PIT 300
Spike Shannon NY 295
Fred Tenney BOS 282
Miller Huggins CIN 273
Mike Mitchell CIN 267
Ed Abbaticchio PIT 265

1907- American League

Runs Produced
Ty Cobb DET 211
Sam Crawford DET 179
Harry Davis PHI 163
Sock Seybold PHI 145
Jiggs Donahue CHI 143
Hal Chase NY 138
Elmer Flick CLE 135
George Stone STL 132
Ed Hahn CHI 132
Claude Rossman DET 129

Bases Produced
Ty Cobb DET 360
Elmer Flick CLE 331
Sam Crawford DET 323
George Stone STL 320
Topsy Hartsel PHI 312
Harry Davis PHI 292
Bob Ganley WAS 284
Ed Hahn CHI 275
Charlie Hemphill STL 259
Socks Seybold PHI 255

1908- National League

Runs Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 199
Mike Donlin NY 171
Fred Tenney NY 148
Cy Seymour NY 147
Sherry Magee PHI 134
Fred Clarke PIT 134
Hans Lobert CIN 130
Joe Tinker CHI 129
Tommy Leach PIT 129
Harry Steinfeldt CHI 124

Bases Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 415
Hans Lobert CIN 355
Red Murray STL 322
Mike Donlin NY 321
Sherry Magee PHI 301
Tommy Leach PIT 300
Fred Clarke PIT 289
Joe Tinker CHI 276
John Titus PHI 274
Fred Tenney NY 266

1908- American League

Runs Produced
Ty Cobb DET 192
Sam Crawford DET 175
Nap Lajoie CLE 149
Germany Schaefer DET 145
Fielder Jones CHI 141
Matty McIntyre DET 133
Hobe Ferris STL 126
Jake Stahl BOS 126
Harry Davis PHI 122
Amby McConnell BOS 118

Bases Produced
Ty Cobb DET 349
Sam Crawford DET 322
Matty McIntyre DET 321
George Stone, STL 292
Nao Lajoie CLE 280
Germany Schaefer DET 277
Fielder Jones CHI 274
Topsy Hartsel PHI 270
Harry Davis PHI 264
Patsy Dougherty CHI 262

1909- National League

Runs Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 187
Mike Mitchell CIN 165
Ed Konetchy STL 164
Tommy Leach PIT 163
Fred Clarke PIT 162
Red Murray NY 158
Dots Miller PIT 150
Bobby Byrne STL 131
Harry Steinfeldt CHI 130
Larry Doyle NY 129

Bases Produced
Honus Wagner PIT 343
Mike Mitchell CIN 319
Ed Konetchy STL 318
Fred Clarke PIT 316
Larry Doyle NY 315
Tommy Leach PIT 309
Red Murray NY 303
Sherry Magee PHI 289
Al Burch BRO 287
John Titus PHI 278

1909 American League

Runs Produced
Ty Cobb DET 214
Sam Crawford DET 174
Eddie Collins PHI 157
Frank Baker PHI 154
Donie Bush DET 147
Harry Davis PHI 144
Tris Speaker BOS 143
Clyde Engle NY 134
Patsy Dougherty BOS 125
Danny Murphy PHI 125

Bases Produced
Ty Cobb DET 420
Eddie Collins PHI 382
Sam Crawford DET 343
Tris Speaker BOS 314
Donie Bush DET 308
Home Run Baker PHI 288
Patsy Dougherty CHI 279
Danny Murphy PHI 277
Harry Davis PHI 269
Harry Lord BOS 250

Cumulative Runs Produced Rankings

Cap Anson 119
Honus Wagner 105
King Kelly 76
Hugh Duffy 75
Dan Brouthers 73

Nap Lajoie 69
Jim O’Rourke 64
Ed Delahanty 60
Harry Stovey 57
Roger Connor 55

Sam Thompson 54
Sam Crawford 54
Ross Barnes 49
Deacon White 49
Cal McVey 47

George Gore 46
Jimmy Collins 42
George Wright 41
Harry Davis 41
Elmer Flick 39

Joe Kelley 39
Tip O’Neill 38
Long John Reilly 37
George Davis 37
Tommy Leach 34

Cumulative Base Production Ranking

Honus Wagner 96
Cap Anson 91
Billy Hamilton 89
Harry Stovey 88
Dan Brouthers 83

Ed Delahanty 79
Jim O’Rourke 73
Roger Conner 70
Jesse Burkett 63
King Kelly 57

Sam Crawford 55
Elmer Flick 53
Hugh Duffy 53
Ross Barnes 50
Charlie Jones 45

Sherry Magee 44
Abner Dalrymple 42
George Wright 41
Pete Browning 41
Topsy Hartsel 41

Paul Hines 40
Napoleon Lajoie 39
Lip Pike 39
Fred Clarke 37
Mike Tiernan 35
 
THE PLAYERS

The dominant team of this period featured neither Wagner or Cobb. It didn’t feature Nap Lajoie, either.

Bill James: “The Chicago Cubs in 1906 won 116 games. This remains the record for most wins in a season. The Cubs also won 223 games in two years, (1906-07), which is the record for wins in a two-season span, and 322 games over three years (1906-08), which is the record for wins over a three years span. They won 426 games over a four season span (1906-09), which is the record for wins over a four year span, and they won 530 games over a five year span (1906-1910), which is the record for wins over a period of five years. The Cubs won 622 games over a six year span, (1905-1910), which is a record by far…The Cubs won 715 games in seven years (1904-1910): this is also a record. They won 807 games in an eight-year period, (1904-11), which, again, is a record…They won 898 games between 1904 and 1912, which is the record for wins over a nine-year period and they won 986 between 1904-1913, which is a record for wins over a ten year period.” In other words, the Cubs were pretty good. The core of this stretch is 1906-10 when they averaged 106 wins per year- in a 154 game season, won four pennants, (they won 104 games in 1909, the most ever for a second place team), and their only two World Series.

Why were they so great? James attributes it to the famous double play combination of “Tinker to Evers to Chance”, saying that “When you look carefully at the Cubs of those years, it is impossible to avoid the conclusion that this team won more games with infield defense than any other team in the history of baseball.” Well, looking at team defensive numbers, we see that they led the National league in fielding percentage four times in five years from 1906-10. They tied for second the other time. They led in double plays only once. They were third three times and 6th the other time. Offensively, they led in runs once, were second twice , 3rd and 4th the other two years. They had the identical rankings for batting average. They were second in on base percentage tree times and twice led in slugging percentage. They were a good offensive team by the standards of the day, but not dominant. But they did have a dominant pitching staff, leading in ERA four times in 5 years and finishing second the other years. They led the league in WHIP, (walks and hits per inning) all five years.

James ranked the top 125 players at each position in baseball history, except he only ranked 100 pitchers. (He had ranked the top 400 but his computer crashed and there wasn’t enough time to redo it before his New Historical Baseball Abstract was due to be published.) He ranked only one Cubs pitcher from this era in his top 100: Mordecai “Three Finger Brown”, who once beat Christy Matheson nine straight times. James dismisses the rest of the staff as not having comparable success with other teams, saying that “the Cubs’ defense was so good that anybody they put on the mound was effective”. Jack Pfeister was 70-40 for the Cubs, 1-4 for other teams. Ed Reulbach was 136-65 for the Cubs, 46-41 for other teams. Carl Lundgren was 91-55 for the Cubs, the only team he played for. Jack Taylor was 109-90 for the Cubs, 43-49 for other teams. Orvall Overall was 86-43 for the Cubs, 22-28 for other teams. “King” Cole was 40-13 for the Cubs, 14-14 for other teams. Lew Ritchie was 44-27 for the Cubs, 30-38 for other teams. Brown, himself, was 188-86 for the Cubs and 20-25 for other teams. These guys were not just along for the ride. Their prime years were when they were Cubs. But they obviously benefited from being on the Cubs.

The Cubs everyday starters in the 1906-10 period were Johnny Kling and Jimmy Archer catching, Frank Chance at first, Johnny Evers at second, Joe Tinker at short, Harry Steinfeldt at third, Frank “Wildfire” Schulte in left, Jimmy Slagle and Solly Hofman in center and Jimmy Sheckard in right. James rates Kling as the #48 catcher of all time, Chance as the #25 first baseman, Evers as the #25 second baseman, Tinker as the #33 shortstop, Steinfeldt as the #57 third baseman, Schulte as the #60 right fielder, Slagle the #101 center fielder, Hofman as the #106 center fielder and Sheckard as the #24 right fielder.

My image of the 1906-10 Cubs is similar to that of the 1996-2000 Yankees, who were said not have any stars, although some players certainly emerged as stars. What they didn’t have was a Barry Bonds, Sammy Sosa or Mark McGwire, individuals having statistically overwhelming seasons. What they did have was a line-up that featured a superior player at every position in the field and every spot in the batting order and a pitching staff that had a good pitcher in every spot in the rotation. The total was greater than the sum of each part. The baseball season isn’t a test of how great your greatest player is but of your total roster. The 1906-10 Cubs were simply a great team.

The two big individual stories of the half-decade were the total dominance of Honus Wagner in the National League and the emergence of TY COBB as the dominant figure in the American league. That Cobb was one of the very greatest players of all time is well-known. He has the game’s all-time batting average, either .367 or .366, depending on the source. (His numbers are so committed to the memory of baseball fans that they object when they are revised.) He compiled that mostly in the Dead Ball Era whereas Rogers Hornsby, the second place guy with .358, did most of his hitting in the Live Ball Era. #3 Joe Jackson, (.356) was a Cobb contemporary but had his career cut short by the Black Sox scandal and never had any declining years. They are the only guys who batted .350 or better lifetime. Cobb won 12 or 13 batting titles, depending on the source. (The year in dispute is the one where the St. Louis manager left Nap Lajoie get 6 bunt singles in a double header to catch him). Cobb hit an average of 97 points above the league in his career and from 1909-1919 he was an average of 131 points above the league with a high of 147 in 1911. Hornsby was an average of 61 points above the league in his career with a high of 141 in 1924, when he hit .424. Hornsby famously had a .402 batting average over a five year period from 1921-25. He was an average of 113 points over the league in that stretch.

Cobb was probably the greatest base-runner of all time. He stole 892 bases and led the league six times. And this was after the definition of stolen base had been changed to what it is now. In Billy Hamilton’s day, if you went from 1st to third on a single, that was a stolen base. Cobb also had 54 inside the park home runs and 295 triples. He became the epitome and champion of “inside” baseball. Most of the players of his day had come up the hard way, often wondering where their next meal was coming from and a game based on figuring out how to negotiate one base at a time seemed to symbolize their lives. The aggression with which they, and especially Cobb, fought for the next base symbolized the toughness that everyday life required in their day. Later, as America emerged as a world power and science was coming up with new miracles every day, fans had a taste to be awed by something and the empshsis in baseball changed to hitting home runs.

Cobb was a fairly big guy, about 6-2 and 180 and hit the ball hard. He led the league in slugging percentage nine times in a row. Per 162 games he hit an average of 39 doubles, 16 triples and 6 home tunes for 61 extra base hits. (Mickey Mantle, playing his entire career in the Live Ball Era, was 23-6-36 = 64).Like Wagner, if Cobb had come up in the Live Ball Era, he might have been a 500 home run guy in addition to has other accomplishments. In 1925, Cobb, then age 38, got so sick of hearing about Babe Ruth’s home run hitting that he told a reporter he was going to swing for the fences. That day he went 6 for 6 with three home runs. When asked about this, Ruth responded: “"I could have had a lifetime .600 average, but I would have had to hit them singles. The people were paying to see me hit home runs."

Cobb seems to have been a Jekyll and Hyde personality, with Mr. Hyde being his public persona. There’s a famous story of Cobb’s one confrontation with Honus Wagner, in the final World Series of this decade. “There is a long-standing legend that Cobb, standing on first base, called the German-ancestored Honus Wagner "Krauthead", told him he was going to steal second, and was not only thrown out but that Wagner tagged him in the mouth, ball in hand, drawing blood from Cobb's lip. However, an examination of the play-by-play does not indicate that such a play occurred. In the one "caught stealing" charged to Cobb, during the first inning of Game 4, he was actually safe at second due to a throwing error by first baseman Bill Abstein. This story is largely attributed to the creative press at the time, and Wagner and Cobb were actually on good terms.” But apocryphal stories often have a grain of truth to them: they are concocted and believed because they adhere to the images the people in them have.

There are well-documented cases of Cobb’s racism and capacity for violence. "In 1907 during spring training in Augusta, Georgia, a black groundskeeper named Bungy, whom Cobb had known for years, attempted to shake Cobb’s hand or pat him on the shoulder." The overly familiar greeting infuriated Cobb, who attacked Bungy. When Bungy's wife tried to defend him, Cobb choked her. The assault was only stopped when catcher Charles "Boss" Schmidt knocked Cobb out. In 1908, Cobb attacked a black laborer in Detroit who complained when Cobb stepped into freshly poured asphalt; Cobb was found guilty of battery but the sentence was suspended”…. “He once slapped a black elevator operator for being "uppity." When a black night watchman intervened, he pulled out a knife and stabbed him… A police warrant was issued for his arrest. Cobb pleaded guilty to assault and battery after the season, paid a $100 fine, and had to settle a civil suit with the man he assaulted.””

His two most famous incidents were an attack on a fan in New York in 1912 and the supposed killing of a man in Detroit not long afterwards. The fan was calling him a “half-ni—er” and Cobb was actually urged by this teammates to do something about the heckler, he jumped into the stands and started to beat him up. “When onlookers shouted at him to stop because the man had no hands, he reportedly retorted, "I don't care if he got no feet!". Cobb apparently did have a confrontation with three men who jumped him in Detroit and Cobb chased them away with a gun. The newspapers of the time reported the incident but said nothing about a killing and nobody ever turned up. The allegation that Cobb killed one of his assailants first comes up in Al Stump’s book on Cobb, which was published a half century later and the accuracy of which has been brought into considerable question.

Cobb was the product of a racist society: not just Georgia but the United States in general as represented by baseball ‘s “gentleman’s agreement” to not use black players. The fact that his teammates urged him to attack the heckler and went on strike when he suspended because of it tells you about their attitude. That Cobb failed to rise above this is hardly to his credit but it’s wrong to single him out as a racist. What made him a symbol of it was his prominence as a player, his popularity in the south and his violent temper.

That temper seems have stemmed from tragedy and insecurity. His mother killed his father shortly before his big league debut, thinking he was a prowler, (he thought she was having an affair and was spying upon her). He wanted to impress his father and was always angry that he never got to see his son play. His Detroit teammates subjected him to a severe rookie hazing, intensified by the fact that he was southern kid playing for a northern team and a rural kid playing in the big city. He reacted angrily, which only made it worse. "These old-timers turned me into a snarling wildcat." Bill James talks extensively about Cobb looking insecure in virtually every picture taken of him during his playing career. “Ty Cobb’s racism and his anger, I believe, were fueled not by smugness or even resentment but by an unusually intense fear of his own limitations. No one is more macho than a man who feels inadequate.”

Cobb apparently mellowed after his career. There are many stories of his kindnesses to individuals, including young players. He praised Jackie Robinson and said, in 1952, "Let me say also that no white man has the right to be less of a gentleman than a colored man; in my book that goes not only for baseball but in all walks of life." Ernie Harwell, perhaps the most liked man in baseball with Cobb the most hated, liked and respected his fellow Georgian. James: “If one were to take the time to document a thousand instances in which Ty Cobb went out of his way to be kind to other people, including black people, would that change his image? I fear it would not...the bell cannot be unrung…..When Ty Cobb felt threatened he lashed out at the world. He felt threatened a lot- but as long as he wasn’t challenged, he was a very nice man.” If you were trying to get him out, you were challenging him.

Some players you may not have heard of:

CY SEYMOUR had one of the all-time “career years”. In 1905 he led the National League in batting average, hits, doubles, triples and RBIs. He never led the league in anything in any other year of a 16 year career. He started out as a pitcher and is one of two players to have 50 pitching wins and 50 home runs. You can guess who the other is.

SHERWOOD “SHERRY” MAGEE was the opposite- a player with a long, productive career, leading the leading in RBIS four times, the first in 1907 and the last in 1918. He labored for bad Phillie teams for 11 years and got traded the year before they finally made the World Series, (1915). But he did get into the 1919 Series, helping the Reds win with a hit. He also had a bit of Cobb in him. Christy Mathewson: “He is bad when irritated- and tolerable easy to irritate.”

George and Harry Davis were not related but, like Magee, they had long and productive careers. George’s career began back in 1890 but he was still going strong until 1909. He hit over .300 nine times and led the NL with 135 RBIs in 1897. He also stole 619 bases. He played most of his career for the Giants and White Sox. He was no “hitless wonder”, hitting .308 to help the Sox beat the ’06 Cubs. A contemporary article describes George as “one of the greatest and brainiest players of the present day.” Also the bravest. One day, on the way to the ballpark, he saw smoke rising from an apartment building and saved two woman and child by the use of a ladder. “Once I thought I was going to be cut off by the flames from reaching a child that was holding its arms out to me. But I got through and reached the ground without either one of us being hurt.”

Harry was the hitting star of Connie Mack’s first Athletic pennant winners. He led the AL in home runs four years in a row, 1904-1907, twice in RBIs and three times in doubles. He was described as “The man who is known in baseball circles as the smartest and craftiest player in the history of the game.” The article says that he hit a home run over the center field fence in Detroit that “is regarded among baseball men as the longest hit ever made in the major leagues.” Babe Ruth, according to Bill Jenkinson, had hit a drive over Detroit’s center field fence of 575 three years before that article. Harry had an even longer career than George: 1895-1917, sixteen of those years for Mr. Mack, who called him “The squarest man I ever knew”.

Another smart man was Topsy Hartsel, who also played for Mr. Mack and led the AL in walks five times. . He set a record with 121 walks in 1905, that lasted until Babe Ruth. And nobody was intentionally walked, or even ptiche3d around in those days. There was no fear of the long ball. Bill James rates him the third greatest lead-off hitter of all time, behind Ricky Henderson and Tim Raines. Why was he named after a character in Uncle Tom’s Cabin? No idea. (No, he was never a teammate of Bill “Little Eva” Lange from the previous decade.)

The strongest man in baseball at the time was surely 6-0 225 Sam Mertes, who was nicknamed “Sandow” after a famous circus strongman of the period. Hit hitting helped the Giants win the 1905 pennant, (10-8 RBIs), and he made what John McGraw called “the greatest catch I ever saw” to clinch it. “Starting with the crack of the bat he looked squarely into the sun and ran with the ball. It seemed certain it would go over his head. By a sprint, though, he got back and, with a jump, speared the ball with his bare hand, crashing into the fence as he fell. But he had saved the game and won the pennant.” It must have seemed like an optical illusion to some…
 

Forum statistics

Threads
170,322
Messages
4,884,907
Members
5,991
Latest member
CStalks14

Online statistics

Members online
246
Guests online
1,392
Total visitors
1,638


...
Top Bottom