Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="anomander, post: 1065710, member: 2766"]
It really is ridiculous how big of a gap it is.  Personally I tend to agree a lot more with the 2 4 7 ratings.  Sure it's easy to say because it's the better graded class, but I would have graded our guys the exact same way.  I would have pegged Byrne, Spence, and Robinson as our lowest commits, and that matches up to what 2 4 7 has.  You could say they had Perkins graded a little high, but they gave a solid breakdown to support it at least.

As for Skout and Rivalz there is no way Sam Clausman is only a  2 star.  Hell Skout has John Phillips as a 3 star.

I think what it comes down to is that Rivalz and Skout factor camp performances into their ratings, while 2 4 7 says they don't really factor that into the grades.  Looking at our commits there aren't a lot of camp kids, which makes sense the 2 4 7 rating is higher.  For example I know for a fact Perkins and Fredericks were supposed to attend a Rivalz camp right after they committed, but never showed.  No surprise they are 2 stars at Rivalz.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?