Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="upperdeck, post: 3227022, member: 474"]
what would people rank these if they were not  series of movies but just a single movie with no prequel or sequel ?     Some of he complaints about any single movie are because they didnt advance a story  in a way that people wanted.    How would star wars have been presented if going in they knew 5/6 were really getting done like lord of the rings did?

now we complain about 9 trying to tie up 40 yrs worth of bows?

i see all these and love it when it completes something but this isnt a tv series trying to end something in the same way and if it leaves something unsaid thats fine to me.

if this was 1-2-3 instead of 7-8-9 i think people would feel differently and if 1-2-3 were the beginning  not sure 2-3 ever get done..   You have to wonder if 4 came out now would it be as loved for a 5-6 because it had a lot of holes too.  but being a new thing to people, it took off and now has had decades to build it up.

we should appreciate that those of us young enough to remember what 4-5-6 were when they came out that 40 yrs later we got to revisit it in a pretty cool way.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?