Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="sufandu, post: 4773999, member: 874"]
He picked defenses apart behind a really good offensive line, at least after Pugh came back, and while being supported by a really good running game after the coaching staff stumbled upon a offensive scheme change in the preseason. He ran that offense really well. But he was never asked to escape pressure and make plays on his own the way Shrader has. And Nassib had the one really good year while the first two were pretty average. Shrader has carried the offense ever since he was handed the keys. If we swap the two players, I suspect the 2010-2012 offense fairs better with Shrader than the 2021-2023 offense does with Nassib. There's no way to prove thag, but that's my opinion after watching both play.

Incidentally, Shrader's passer rating was actually a bit higher last year than Nassib's was his senior year, his highest. TD/Int were very similar to a slight advantage for Nassib, Shrader averaged a little more ypa and ypc. The two biggest differences were Nassib having more passing attempts to get his passing stats and Shrader generating significantly more production on the ground.

And so far this year Shrader's passer rating rating is significantly higher still than last year. So, I'll stick with my opinion. I would take Shrader over Nassib as a college QB.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?