What the committee should do IMO

[HRE Otto IV]

I would ask these questions:

How many Ws do you have over NCAAT teams?
How many Ls do you have to teams definitely out?
How many W & L do you have against fellow Bubble teams?

Looking at the non P5 teams we have:

Temple
1st in AAC
Ws over NCAAT teams: TBD
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Houston, Memphis (could win AACT), ECU, Tulsa
Ws over Bubble teams: Cincy 2x, UConn 2x (could move up to Ws over NCAAT team)
Ls to Bubble teams: UConn (could move out if UConn wins)
They beat Memphis once (AAC CG) and SMU once

Cincy
3 way tie for 3rd in AAC
Ws over NCAAT teams: TBD
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Tulsa, Memphis (could be removed), Houston
Ws over Bubble teams: VCU, UConn 2x (could move)
Ls to Bubble teams: Temple 2x, UConn (could move)
They beat Memphis once (AAC CG) and SMU once

UConn
6th in AAC (can win AACT)
Ws over NCAAT teams: Texas
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Tulsa, Houston
Ws over Bubble teams: Michigan, Cincy, Temple
Ls to Bubble teams: Temple 2 x, Cincy 2x, SU
Beat SMU once and lost to SU head to head

VCU
3 way tie for 1st in A10
Ws over NCAAT teams: Middle Tennessee St, Buffalo, St Joes
Ls to non NCAAT teams: FSU, GA Tech, GW, UMass, George Mason
Ws over Bubble teams: St Bonnie
Ls to Bubble teams: Cincy

St Bonnie
3 way tie for 1st in A10
Ws over NCAAT teams: Buffalo, Dayton, St Joes 2x
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Hofstra, Siena, Duquesne, Lasalle, Davidson
Ws over Bubble teams: None
Ls to Bubble teams: SU, VCU
Lost to SU head to head

Monmouth
1st in MAAC
Ws over NCAAT teams: ND, USC, Iona
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Canisius, Army,. Manhattan
Ws over Bubble teams: None
Ls to Bubble teams: None

Valpo
1st in Horizon
Ws over NCAAT teams: Iona, Oregon State, Green Bay 2x
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Ball State, Belmont, Wright State 2x
Ws over Bubble teams: None
Ls to Bubble teams: None

San Diego St
1st in MWC
Ws over NCAAT teams: Cal, Fresno St
Ls to non NCAAT teams: San Diego, Grand Canyon, Boise Sate
Ws over Bubble teams: None
Ls to Bubble teams: None

Wichita St
1st in MVC
Ws over NCAAT teams: Utah, Northern Iowa
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Tulsa, Bama, Illinois State
Ws over Bubble teams: None
Ls to Bubble teams: None

St Mary’s
1st in WCC
Ws over NCAAT teams: Gonzaga 2x
Ls to non NCAAT teams: BYU, Pepperdine 2x
Ws over Bubble teams: None
Ls to Bubble teams: None

When you compare these teams to SU do we not come out on top?

SU
Ws over NCAAT teams: ND, Duke, A&M (best of any here)
Ls to non NCAAT teams: St Johns, Georgetown, FSU, Clemson
Ws over Bubble teams: UConn, St Bonnie
Ls to Bubble teams: None

 

[upperdeck]

if you do it this way its not even close since none else has wins like ours.

 

[HRE Otto IV]

Adding in other P5 schools

Oregon State
Ws over NCAAT teams: Iona, Oregon, Cal, Utah
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Stanford, UCLA, ASU
Ws over Bubble teams: USC
Ls to Bubble teams: Valpo, USC

USC
Ws over NCAAT teams: Yale, Zona, Colorado
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Washington, ASU, Stanford
Ws over Bubble teams: Monmouth, Oregon St
Ls to Bubble teams: Monmouth, Wichita St, Oregon St

Michigan
Ws over NCAAT teams: Texas, MD, Purdue, Indiana
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Ohio State
Ws over Bubble teams: None
Ls to Bubble teams: UConn (could move to NCAAT team)
How is Michigan not a lock?

Florida
Ws over NCAAT teams: St Joes, WV
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Bama, LSU, Tenn, FSU
Ws over Bubble teams: None
Ls to Bubble teams: South Carolina, Vandy 2x

Vandy
Ws over NCAAT teams: Stony Brook, A&M, UK
Ls to non NCAAT teams: LSU, Arkansas, Miss, Miss St, Tenn
Ws over Bubble teams: Florida 2x
Ls to Bubble teams: South Carolina

South Carolina
Ws over NCAAT teams: A&M
Ls to non NCAAT teams: Bama, Tenn, UGA 3x, Miss St, Mizzou
Ws over Bubble teams: Vandy, Florida
Ls to Bubble teams: None
Plus Memphis if they win the AACT
How is this team even considered?

 

[HRE Otto IV]

if you do it this way its not even close since none else has wins like ours.

Shouldn't that be how it is done? Look at your good wins. Look at your bad losses. Look at the teams you are competing against for the at large bid (bubbles). You shouldn't be punished for losing to good teams. You shouldn't get a reward for playing bad teams. All that should matter is those games listed above. It is insane that people are stuck on computer rankings or Top 50 or 100 records (which are biased since that uses the worst computer ranking the RPI).

 

[HRE Otto IV]

Also 3 of our 4 losses where without JB.

 

[CorduroyG]

Who did you play, who did you beat is 1 of their big sayings.

 

[Briancuse]

Who did you play, who did you beat is 1 of their big sayings.

If thats the case we are in good shape, if we don't get in the saying is a load of crap.