Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="RF2044, post: 1903175, member: 40"] [U]MY[/U] initial assertion is that OL has been a trouble spot for our program dating back for 20+ years, which is 100% true. When we were recruiting Chad Mavety a couple of years ago, one of the Rutgers OL who was in the NFL poked fun of him having SU on his list. Paraphrasing: "why would you go there? they don't put anybody in the NFL" That was pre-Pugh getting drafted, and reflected the perception of the talent we were fielding. Not only have we lacked talent at OL dating back to the P era, we've also placed very few of them at the next level. Not that having NFL prospects is the end all be all, but it suggests something about the players [considered in aggregate] that we've marched out there for the last two decades. You referenced Chibane and Trudo. Nothing against either of those guys, but both were players who saw the field early and showed a lot of potential, but also plateaued early. Bringing them up again demonstrates that you don't see the forest through the trees re: the most important factor: those were perfectly serviceable players, but they weren't as good as the guys our peer programs were playing on THEIR offensive lines, and they certainly weren't NFL caliber talents. How many OL has a peer program like BC put in the NFL over the last 20 years? How about Pitt? Now, compare that to the paltry list of names you're bringing up. Also, I shouldn't have to explain this, but we play [U]5 offensive lineman at the same time[/U]. 1 stud can certainly improve the play of the entire unit [a la Pugh in 2012], but the fact remains that most years we haven't had that stud, and often were only fielding 2-3 OL that would even be in the rotations of many of our opponents. So for all of the rationalizing you've done referencing the Chibane's and Trudo's, the fact is that our OLs have generally trended from god awful to decidedly subpar, far beyond the memory of players like Chad Mavety when we recruited him. OL has been a systemic problem at SU for a LONG time. [/QUOTE]

Verification: What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?