Reply to thread

Message

[QUOTE="Dick_in_MI, post: 77571, member: 225"]
I disagree...my interpretation is that the poster went into the discussion with an opinion of Southerland and manipulated his stats to make a point.

I tend to agree that you can't discount the past until it has been shown that the trend has changed. That said, he isn't making the same arguments about Fab and Dion...both of whom have played well this year but have not historically.

He uses last year's stats to say that JS is the 10th man but if you use last year's stats, you could clearly say the same about Fab. Why is he not taking the same position there? I mean, if you want to include last year in your overall assessment of Fab, you could jusifiably conclude that he was more qualified to be a bridge support than a D1 center. But guys get better and this poster...the same one who unleashed a flurry of quotes from other posters that he has been keeping in his creepy personal database on the football board...seems to have trouble if one of those players is a guy that he has unshakable opinions on.
[/QUOTE]

Verification

What is a Syracuse fan's favorite color?